Hunan's Effect on Peace—The Abandonment of Changsha—Comment on the Japanese Note Naturally, the fall of Changsha has been the chief topic for comment in the Chinese Press during the last week. The next question which has apparently engrossed public interest is the query, "Peace or war?" As a diplomatic document, the latest Note addressed to the Waichizopu by Mr. Obata, the Japanese Minister, has been the subject of much scathing criticism. The action, taken almost at the same time _by the provincial assemblies of Kiangsu and Chéking in the arraignment of their civil governors who happen to be brothers, has received favourable comment; while the suggestion to permit Loys and girls to attend the same school, on which subject Mrs. Dewey has recently lectured at Hangchow, is considered to be yet too premature for adoption in this country.
Of local' affairs, the exorbitant cost of rice, the sudden fall in exchange, the formation of a thrift society and the strike declared by carpenters and masons have given the Chinese Press ample subjects on which to ventilate their views.
Hunan Arrain anp Peace.
Under the above heading, the furlan affair, in the opinion of the "Shunpao," can neither help nor stultify the consummation of the peace movement, "Judging from its attitude, the Southern Army appears to' be disinclined to go beyond Changsha and to invade hupeh. Nor does the Anhui clique seem to be in a position to warrant the belief that they are capable of passing through Honan and Hupeh, now in the hands of the Chihli party, in order to recapture Changsha.
"Actual fighting may thus be prevented from being continued after Changsha has fallen, unless the Chihli leaders should choose to force an issue with the Anhuiese, in which event the rival forces may meet in combat onthe plains of our central provinces, which is by no means an unlikely contingency. However, the Anhui leaders should by now admit that they have reotived a staggering blow if not a ofushing defeat. May the fervent prayer of our people that the contending parties may soon end their quarrel and come to terms without causing further devastations be granted by Heaven!"
The paper goes on to explain that true and permanent peace can only be secured by the manifestation of sincerity and good faith on both sides. Neither should the North, as a whole, take advantage of the split in the South by siding with Yunnan to beat Kuangsi, nor should the Anhui faction try score over its rival, the Chihli Party, by enlisting ' the hein of Yunnan, "Intrigues and stratagems may triumph for a time; but peace won by such underhand means can never endure and is therefore really no peace" is the decided view of the "Shunpao.":
Tue Fatt or Cuanasna.
With one accord, the Chinese Press severely condemn Chang Chin-yao, the Tuchun of Hunan, for his precipitate retreat from Ghangsha. The "'Shunpao" stigmatizes his conduct as "utterly unsoldierly,"" and apart from any consideration of the national interest of China, it asks, "Was it not a most disgraceful and humiliating thing for the party concerned to think that it should have reposed so much confidence in such a cowardly and worthless catspaw as Chang The "New Shun Pao" remarks that it was only a matter of 17 days from May 93 on which the 3rd Division of General Wu Pei-fu began to withdraw from the front lines of defence in Hunan, and the Southern Army began their advance, to June_11 on which evening' Chang Chin-yao and his hordes retreated from Changsha Yochow. It points out several facts which need elucidation: First, why had all the Northern troops retreated without any fight, thus causing Changsha to fall into Southern control? Second, according to Chang's report, he delegated Li Kuei-yuan to preserve order before he ott Changsha for the front; how was it that when the Southerners entered Changsha on the 12th instant, Li Kuei-yuan was reported to have arrived at Hankow on the 11th? The city must have been left to the mercy of marauders for one day at least? Third, why and by whose authority had Wu Pei-fu seized and detained the consignments of arms and ammunition sent by Peking to Chang Chin-yao?
Tue Precious Miritary Carcase.
In a sarcastic strain, the "View Shun Pao" relieves itscit of its feelings thus "Funds may be energetically amassed. Yaméns may be volun tarily set on fire. The trust by the Government may be conveniently forgotten. The misdirection of his troops may be explained by lame excuses. The property and lives of hundreds of thousands of people may be abandoned. But my own precious carcase must be protected from all alarm and danger so that it will not receive the slightest injury. Asked why, his blatant answer would be 'Oh! I was obliged to act as I did'."
In addition to condemning Chang Chin-yao for deserting his post without showing fight, the "Sinwanpao" has something constructive to say. ltattributes the defeat of the Northern troops, if defeat we could term it, primarily to the lack of responsibility prevalent at Peking. It attributes the hostile actions taken by Tan Yen-kai, the Southern commander, to the lack of responsibility in Canton. As General Chin Yun-peng continues on leave while Admiral C. P. San
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.