The Archive · 1920

Indigo Contract Claim

Plea of Force Majeure for Non-Delivery In H. M. Supreme Court on Wednesday the case of the Tsing Yue Dyes Ca. v. Frederick Large & Ca. came before His Honour Judge Skinner Turrer. This was a for Tls. 43.125.80 damages arising out of an alleged breach of contract, Mr. W. 8. Levinson appeared for plaintiffs and Mr. Reader Harris for defendants.

Plaintiffs are a Chinese dye company carrying on business in Shanghai and other places, and the defendant firm_a British company, at Shanghai. On December 10 last a contract in writing was entered into by the parties for sale and delivery of 50 tons of 20 per cent. Paste Indigo at G.80.84 per lb., Shanghai-.840 piculs at G.8112.006 per picul. According to the statement of claim, it was a term of the contract that the goods were to be shipped from Marseilles within 30 days of the date of the contract. The defendants failed to ship the goods, and by letter of their solicitors, dated April 6 of this year, refused to deliver the indigo or carry out the contract.

The amount claimed by plaintiffs was the sum of losses sustained on five contracts for the re-sale of the -|indigo which defendants failed to supply, the amounts in respect each contract being: Ts. 4,580, Tls. 4,730, Tls. 4,880, Tls. 10,160, and Tls. 8,583; together with Tls. 10,492, the sum of loss of profit or differ: ence between the contract price, Tls. 76.20, and the market price, Tls. 125 prevailing on the day complainants were informed that defendants would not deliver the indigo.

Tae Derence-

In his statement, of defence, de-tendent admitted that on December 10 last he entered into a contract with the plaintiffs, but alleged that plaintiffs had not correctly set forth the terms of the contract. It was provided that shipment should be made within 30 days from Marseilles, "but no guarantee is made as to the date of delivery or arrival of cargo." There was a further clause that force majeure would

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account