The Archive · 1920

U. S. Court for China

Shanghai, June 10.

Before Hon. C. S. Losixarer, Judge.

Mercantile Bank of India, Ld. v.

Caravel & Ca,, Inc.

Judgement in the above action was delivered as follow Lobingier, J.—The amended petition in this cause alleges that "On the 20th day of September, 1919, the defendants entered into a contract with the plaintiff for the purchase by the defendants from thy plaintiff of the equivalent in gold dollars of Tls. 18,000 at exchange 133) September delivery."

It is further alleged that "an order to fix the exchange was given to" an exchange broker by defendant's manager on the instruetions of Mr. Meyersohn, the defendant's director." This entire averment is denied in the amended answer and the sole question is whether defendant entered into such a contract as is here alleged.

There is considerable controversy as to the status and authority of the party who is designated "in the above except as "the defendant's director." His name appears on defendant's letter head though not with any title. He left here on October 4, and defendant deavoured to have his deposition taken in Yokohama but before the interrogatories reached there Meyersohn had left for New York and plaintiff objected to a coatinuance for taking the deposition at that place. His successor with defendant here testifies that Meyersohn, like himself, was "in charge" of the local office but thas the contract of employment of each contained the limitation "that he will not consulate any sale or deal without first receiving the confirnation of" the company and that such is the invariable practice in all transactions, Other portions of plaintiff's evidence, however, render the question here not so much one as to the authority of Meyersohn as the capacity in which he acted during the negotiations which gave rise to this proceeding. For the details the transaction plaintiff relies main-on the testimony of the one de-ignoted in the petition as "defendant's manager" but who, cording to its present represenrative, "was no more than a clerk when Meyersohn was here." This employee states that he had no power of attorney and that any contracts negotiated by him were "subject to Meyersohn's approval." As regards the beginning of this particular transaction he testifies:

What was the first thing Mr.

Meyersohn said to you with regard to exchange?

A—To ascertain the quotations from the banks for demand draft on New York for $24,000.00 gold."

Q—Did you obtain any quotations? A.—I telephoned to the Hongkong Bank they quoted 1303.

Q—Did you whort that to Mr. Meyer.

sohn?

I reported that to him.

Q—What did he say to that A.—He sid that if you would get 131 he would close for 18,000 tacls."* Thereupon, the employee states, he telephoned the broker that "our firm would like to close for Tls. 18,000 at the rate of 131 for demand draft New York."

On cross-examination he testified "Q.—When you showed Mr. Meyersohw this exchange contract, he asked you why tha name of Caravel Ca., Was mentioned, didn't he?

A.—Not at once. After a little conver. sation I had with him he asked me why was the names of Caravel Ca., mentioned and I told him—I said 'Isn't it for the firm? and he said 'No, Carvel € Ca, have nothing to' do with it? and I said "That is very easy, you can ask the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account