The Archive · 1920

Question of Jurisdiction

THE SHOPLIFTERS

At the Mixed Court on Thursday, before Mr. Ivanoff (Russian Assesser) and Magistrate Li, an appeal was heard against an order for the deportation of Zesan Zakofsky and Maria Padeska, convicted of shoplifting in the International Settlement.

Mr. Lemiere appeared. for the appellants, and Mr. R. C. Faithfull represented the Commissioner of Police, upon whose application, made by Inspector Wheeler a week ago, the order for deportation was made.

Mr. Lemiere first pointed out that, as there was no Court of Appeal in Shanghai, an appeal had to take the form of an application for rehearing. He contended that in this case the sentence had been wrongly inflicted, the Court having no jurisdiction. The accused were arrested in the International Settlement on a warrant which was irregular, the accused residing in the French Concession. Up to the time of the order for deportation, Counsel was under the impression that that the accused were Russians, but at that hearing the Assesser held that they were Poles. Accordingly, being resident in the French Concession, they should have been tried by the French Mixed Court. Counsel had since made inquiries and had found that no warrant was issued. Since becoming an independent country, Poland had made no new agreement with China and there was only a gentleman acting as Polish Consul. By agreement he had his office in the French Consulate, and they were acting officially in matters con. cerning Polish subjects. The Frensh Consul held that the Shanghai Municipal Police should have iaformed him that the accused were living in the French Concession, and that they were being prosecnted. Counsel asked for a rehearing of the case on the ground that that Court had no_ jurisdiction, and added that he had authority to say that the French Consul endorsed this view.

Mr. Faithfull pointed out that Mr. Lemiere had no new evidence or other material to furnish in the case. Counsel quoted rules agreed to by the French and International Mixed Courts, and contended that in cases where the accused were of any nationality other than French, and the crime was _committed in the International Settlement, the Mixed Court was the proper court to try the case. The prisoners were not represented by any Consul here, and were amenable to the jurisdiction of this Court only. Since the sentence was passed, Zakofsky had told Det. Schmidt that the accused had made thousands of dollars and that he had got off very lightly. It was a bare-faced crime, and it was most undesirable that the time wrt should be taken up with a trivial application of this character. Reviewing the evidence against the accused, Counsel observed that, had not the accused been identified through the photographs furnished by the Russian authorities, no doubt a number of people in Shang. hai would have been victimized. These people were notorious shoplifters, and the sooner they were deported the better.

The Assessor—The rehearing is not granted.

Mr. Lemiere next appealed against deporting the accused. He argued that sentence once having been passed, the Court could not increase punishment at a later date. He. therefore, asked that the order for deportation be cancelled.

This application was also re fused.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account