Sir Ian Hamilton's Criticism General Sir Ian Hamilton, who was the principal guest at a dinner at Sheffield of the 455th West Riding Field Company, R.E., which served in his command in Gallipoli, referred in the course of a short speech to the campaign on the peninsula.
There is, said General Hamilton, a bond which unites us all, and the meaning and interpretation of that union is. I believe, that we are at one in believing we ought to have ended the war in 1916, at the latest, and that it was not our fault that we did not. As you may know, I have stood aside whilst quite a mass of literature has emerged upon the campaign, All of it is fair and some of it is very fine and very true. But in no case is it clearly brought out that the Higher Direction of the Entente (wherever that might reside) could have taken Constantinople, knocked out the Turks, joined hands with the Russians and immobilized Bulgaria on several occasions, repeatedly, indeed, between the date of our landing on April 25 and the date of our evacuation of Anzac and Suvla Bay.
Whether the landing was possible or not was highly problematical very much open to question. After that, there was no question. The problem became a mere matter of the Higher Direction making up their minds. Be the reason what it may, the Higher Direction of the Entente could not make up their minds. We British never make use of our amphibious power to carry out those movements on the grand scale which go by the name of strategy.
There were periods when we might, without any danger to Calais or Paris, have borrowed for a few days' use the small number of howitzers, trench mortars, and aeroplanes which would have given us absolute success. Mistakes were made, no doubt, both at home and on the spot, but the idea of the Dardanelles was so essential! sound that, once the landing was made good, it must have triumphed had only the reins of our British Direction been held at the real centre of affairs in London instead of—as they were—in Paris and on the Western Front.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.