The Archive · 1923

The Surtax Question

I will now pass to the resolution with, regard to the proposed Customs surtax. As you are aware, the Washington Conference decided that immediate steps shall be taken through a Special Conference to Prepare the way for the speedy abolition of likin and the fulfilment of the other conditions laid down in the Mackay Treaty, and that this Special Conference shall neet within three months from the coming into force of the Treaty and shall consider the interim provisions te be applied prior to the abolition o€ likin, and shall authorize the levying of a surtax at the rate of per cent, on dutiable imports as from such date, for such purposes, and subject to such conditions, as it may determine. The Association of Chamberg considered that this conference was a convenient opportunity to ascertain and give expression to views of British merchants as to the purposes for which this proposed surtax should be used. The resolution on this subject was proposed on behalf of the Shang-bai Chamber by Mr. Arnhold in an extremely able speech which indicated the expenditure of a great amount of time and trouble in going into the financial and other questions involved in this matter. The resolution wag ultimately passed without dissentient vote, In passing this resolution this conference does not assume that the present state of disorder in China has been brought about by want of money. This conference has simply faced the facts. On the one hand there is the resolution of the Washington Conference, under which we may assume that the Special Conference will, at an early date, meet in China to grant and fix the purposes and conditions and the date of coming into force of this surtax. On the other hand there is the state of disorder in China, evidenced, among many other ways, by the appalling list of lootings, burnings and other outrages given in Mr. Lester's speech on the resolution on disorder in China. This conference has endeavoured to suggest a scheme for the use of the proceeds of the surtax, when granted, towards the ending of this terrible state of disorder. The resolution which hag been passed received the most thorough and careful consideration before it was presented to the conference. It was presented in a speech which explained the facts and the arguments on which it is based in an extremely thorough and able manner. It wag passed by this conference without dissentient vote.

It is offered for consideration to those who will have to deal with this matter as a careful expression of a consensus of responsible opin-in. We hope that it will receive due consideration as THE "NORTH-CHINA DAILY News"

CRITICISM, There appeared yesterday a leading article in a newspaper headed "A Great Chance Missed." I do propose to reply to the criticism levelled against our resolution, as that will be done officially by the Association, but I may say that as the first sentence of that article showed that it referred to the resolution, I read it with very great interest, hoping to find, in view of the headline, some alternative and better proposal which, I am sure, from my knowledge of the manner in which this conference hag welcomed and considered different viewpoints, that we should have been glad to consider even after the passing of the resolution. Now the only suggestion I can find in the article is the advice that foreigners should hold rigidly aloof and reject all requests for money. Well, the Special Conference is bound by the Washington Conference to mech and it is bound to grant the surtax and fix the purposes for and conditions on which it is to be used, We offer suggestions as to those purposes and conditions. The time at which it is to come into force is a separate question. We Lelieve that by putting forward our suggestion we have done more wisely than by simply saying to the Special Conference, "Notwithstanding the terms of the mandate under which you are formed we have no suggestion to offer except that you do not! grant the surtax," which is apparently the "great chance" which we have missed.

It is, perhaps, worth mention that although many of the matters discussed during the conference were the subject of brisk debate and the expression of many pointe of view, and several of the resolutions proposed were amended during their discussion, every resolution was in ity final form accepted without dissentient vote.

SINCERE FRIENDSHIP FOR CHINA, I will conclude my remarks' by again pointing out that from the beginning to the end of our agenda there is no resolution which implies any unfriendliness to, or any spirit of aggression against, the Chinese people We sincerely believe that ai] our resolutions tend equally to the good of the Chinese as to ourselves. The resolutions and the speeches which have been made upon them have throughout been animate ed by the most friendly feelings towards the Chinese. They represent a consensus of opinion arrived at after the greatest care and thought and the fullest discussion which we have been able to give to them, and og such they are offered for the consideration of those who may have to deal with the matters which they refer to, and to those in whose capacity it lies to take further steps towards the ends which have been indicated.

Mr. R. H. Clive's Reply toa Criticism Mr. R. H. Clive, orna, H. M Counsellor of Legation, addressed

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account