Mr. Clear referred to the matter as an old bugbear. As a matter of fact the Committee were consider ing this question, but they did not contemplate quite such a dra change. They could not go so far at present as to ask firms to give up their seats. There had been so much controversy over this that he thought they were not in a position to tackle the problem. They had helped to solve it by arranging for seats to be available five minutes before the service.
Mr. Downie maintained that while there were these invidious austinctions between seat holders and non-seat holders there would be unpleasantness. It was not a good thing for the general welfare of the Cathedral and the churchman of Shanghai. He suggested that the question should take the form of an amendment to the budget.
Mr. O, M. Green submitted that the discussion of the resolution could be better dealt with later, under general subjects. Mr. Clear added that it was too late for an emendment to affect the budget.
After further discussion, the following resolution was framed:- "Thiat the budget as printed should be adopted with a recommendation that in the general interests of the congregation measures should be considered for the preparation of future budgets om the basis of the withdrawal of pew rents."
The Dean mentioned that the subject was one that might ko treated quite separately. Afterwards Mr. Downie could put forward his proposition, either in its present or in a more definite form. After all they were only a small meeting. In would be a pity in a statement of annual accounts to bring in something that would caus> a tremendous amount of friction among those absent from the discussion.
The motion was lost, and the budget passed.
The election of officers resulted as follows:—Senior Trustee, Mr W. S. King; Trustees' Warden, Mr. Edney Page; Dean's. Warden, Mr. A. C. Clear; Elected Wardens, Mr. W. S. King, Mr. E. L. Allen, Mr.
J. Dawe, Mr. P. W. O. Liddei!, Mr. O. M. Green, Mr, 8. C. Young and Mr. R. Calder Marshall.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.