Resuming his opening speech for the defendant, Mx. Macleod said! plaintifis'were not entitled to ask jor more than was necessary to protect them, and, if the agreement: went beyond that, it was bad. Defendant did not contest that plaintiffs had recipes which were an improvement on those used by other people.
His Lordship—Nor do you contest that they were known to your client?
Counsel—Certainly, my Lord. There was no evidence to show, Mr. Macleod continued, that defendant was ever in a position to obtain knowledge of or influence with plaintiffs' customers, and the most they could ask in this connexion was some very limited protection with regard to Shanghai. The only point in the case was this: whether, because Messrs. Caldbeck Macgregor had made up certain recipes—no doubt very excellent ones—not known to other people, they were entitled to ask more than that they should protected, against' defendant divulging these secrets or using them himself in competition with plaintiffs. So Jong as these recipes were not divulged or used by defendant, plaintiffs were protected, and counsel did not see anything else for which they could claim protection. The terms of the agreement were such as would debar defendant from serving any other mineral water manufacturer even in the capacity of a motor driver. Plaintifis were seeking
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.