The Archive · 1923

ACCUMULATED SUSPICIONS

In answer to Mr. Goldring, plaintiff said the present charges were based on an accumulation of his suspicions, His Lordship—That is exactly what I should have thought. A geod deal of criticism can. be directed to the circumstances of this sale; criticism, I do not say any more.

Plaintiffi—I think a transaction of this kind in my own lawyer's office was improper.

His Lordship—That is entirely different from charges of fraud and misrepresentation which you are throwing about, Mr. Macdonald then, addressed his Lordship for the defence, and submitted there wag no case for him te meet.

Mr, Goldring disclaimed any motive of malice in the case, and, while admitting that a certain part of his case had broken down, urged that the property was sold at a profit, and was sold through Mr. Kentwell to his own interpreter.

His Lordship—That is not admitted. It is strenuously denied. What is admitted is that the actual document was prepared and signed in Mr. Kentwell's office:

Defendant then gave his- version of the transaction, saying that he himself agreed with plaintiff to purchase the property, being the proprietor of a motor garage and thinking the property could be converted into a repair shop. Finding this would be too expensive, he re-! sold it, receiving $3,000, and $300 commission for having got the lease extended for 18 months,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account