The Archive · 1923

No Case to Answer

His Lordship said he entirely agreed with Mr. Macdonald that defendant had no case to answer. After having reviewed the fasts, his Lordship went on to say he had never before known a case of this character in which plaintiff's first witness was the very charged with making false and fraudulent misrepresentations. Plaintiff was, of course, bound by the answers of his own witness, and if they differed from his own testi-meny, naturally his case failed. That was not the only marvellous part of the case.

The second marvellous thing was that in cross: examination plaintiff expressly withdrew and stated he had never made any charges of fraud against the actual defendant in the writ. There was not a rag of evidence to show that, assuming defendant stated the rentals were only from $4 to $6, and that the highest price obtainable was $3,000, either of the statements were false, and both statements were made by Mr, Kentwell in the Mixed Court. There was not a tittle of evidence to show the property was worth more at that. date, although it would have been perfectly easy to obtain evidence as to its value in 1921. There was ne evidence that fraud in any sense was practised by Mr. Kentwell, and in these circumstances the only thing to do was to dismiss tke action, with costs.

"Tt seems to me hard," his Lordship concluded, "th: under the guise of am action of fraud against. one man, and this charge being withdrawn early in the case, opportunity should be taken to hurl charges of fraud against' another man who is nota party to the suit; and, as far as I am at present advised, I doubt if he could have been made one."

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account