To the Editor of the "'NortH-Curwa Dam News"
Sim—For a good many years T have been a subscriber to the "North China Herald," and have particuarly enjoyed its splendid editorials. Heretofore I have never trespassed on your space with an expression of my personal opinion, but T ean-not: frain from saying a word regarding the foot-note to Dr. Polk's letter in the issue of June 5 just rohand. When the editor of a great. Paper descends to an "ad hominem" slam, like "who expects a Prohibitionist in the modern technical sense of the word, to be logical," I fq: l. thet we prohibifionista have the right to ask what he really means by this astounding insinuation. Does he mean that all the millions of people in the Western world who voted for prohibition are logical?
One knows of the wife of un American multi-millionaire regaling her travelling companions with high sounding diatritzs on the evils of Prohibition—its injustices in taking away the liberties of people, ete—then when she was atone with the missionary, whimpering and crying ik deriding her husband to the devil and saying that if she could, she would send every last. sop of liquor to the bottom of the sea: and no doubt in the secrecy of thie ballot-box that woman voted "for" prohibition. Now was she a Prohibitionist. in the "modern technical sense" or merely a logical one?
Not long age, I was travelling on the China coast. 'Then> was the usual passenger group, indiudirje the tourist, the ihissionary and the customs service man. One of the party was a young Americen, half-drunk most of the tims, who' spent. the day mixing drinks and telling of the position he hoped to secure in a certain port. When the usual discussion on prohibition took place, the young American astounded us al by stating that he would vote for prohibition every time he got the chance—and no doubt he would, Tens of thousands just like him must have voted "for" not "against" in the' many ballots that have been polled. Now, may I ask, what kind of prohibitionists are these people, from the logical point of view? of" the type, oF!
ones?
Whatever kind of! logic these people act upon, it can be at least that it is related most intimately to certain stern facts in the rife of those concerned.
But perhaps by prohibitionists in the "modern technical sense" meant one who does not agree with the logic of facts. Well: here are some facts recently published by one of our British Weeklies—not a church paper: what is the proper logical reaction to these?
"Waar We Srenp ople now spend Education £82,000, 0,000; on" Bread £80, 900,000: Mink '£76,000,000: oni £24,000,000: on Hospitals 000, Fires 265,000,000: on. Old A Drinke £316,000,000.
Now the '"modern-technicaIense"
onists,—the illogical kind—are those that think when more is spent on drink, than for education, for bread, for milk, for coal fires put together, is something wrong—that somewhere, some children are suffering; unjustly suflzring, both sctually and potentially in their lack of educational preparation for life,—and these illogical prohibition fel. lows sey that if personal self-restraint is not sufficient to prevent men working injustice to others then it is time that the opportunity, for working that injastiee, should be removed.
And what about the logic of the appeal to the miracle at Cana, which appears in the same toot rote? A similar appeal could justity slavery. Neither Christ nor the early church definitely opposed slavery. Tt was accepted es part of the social order of the times—but the Spirit of Christ could not stand slavery and threw it off as mankind advanced. Similarly the inferior status of woman was recog nized by the early church but the spirit of Christ finally. demanded equality. And so also with the drink Surely if we are going to be religious about the thing, we might recognize that the spirit of Christ demands that those who claim to be His disciples should not follow without protest, a logie whi allows as much to be spent on drink fires and hospitals combined,'
Tam, ete, RO. Jouuere Chengtu, Sze, June 26, 1926.
Our correspondent surely harps unnecessarily on the phrase "the modern technical sense" which hibition of drink from. prohibition was merely used to distinguish pro.
of other kind The "ad hominem slam" at Dr. Polk's letter we admit was rather "straight from. the shoulder" but what else could the writer of such @ letter expect? end was not that ample of at least one prohibitionist's Tack of legi Is not Mr. Jollife's another, in many ways, but perhaps especially, in his view of the miracle of Cana, For prohibitionists say that the mere act of drinking wine-is wrong, but clearly Christ did not say so: on the contrary He gave the guests more wine, when the first supply was finished.
As for what Britain on rink, will Mr, Jolliffe seriously contend that America spends ess on drink now than she did before prohibition? The present writer was in New York for several days before prohibition came in, and he particularly noticed that everyone drank iced water at meals, wind lists in restaurants were not even offered. Now, by trustworthy. ae-counts, spirituous drinks are almost pushed at one. "Tt may be worth adding that while, driving the years that have elapsed since prohibition came in, crime statistics andthe numbers of people in. gaol in England have steadily decreased, America they have enormously me
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.