The Archive · 1926

THE ACCIDENT TO MR. VAN BUSKIRK

Damages Awarded Against tained While on their hina Press" for Injuries Sus-remises: The Question of a Dangerous Structure In the United States Court for the "China Pross" was in full posses: Ghina on Saturday his Honour|ion and evntrol of that particular Judge Purdy delivered judgment in Part of the premises which was the the action brought by William van scone of the accident, 2nd—That the Buskirk, Deputy United States plaintiff at the time of the accident Marshal, against the "China Press Was not using that part of defen-Incorporated." dant's premises in the ordinary For the plainti Dr. G. Sellett course of business, and was not appeared, while the defendants were there, upon the invitation of def represented by Mfr. S. Fessenden and dunt, cither express or implied. Mr. H. R. Snyder, Srd—Thut it does not appear front A summary of the judgment is as follows:—the evidence that the defendant failed This is an action in which the to keep its premises in a reasonably safe condition, and finally that ever Flaintitt cocks to recover $15,000 though the platform and doorway (United States Currency) as dam-should be found by the court to have ages for personal injuries alleged been of a dangerous character, that have been sustained by the plaintiff in an accident which occurred the accident was the result of plain tift's own negligence and carclesion the premises of defendant—on October 21, 1925, at No. 14 Kiukiang h would bar a recovery n this action, Road in the city of Shanghai. The negligence complained of was the The Control of the Premises construction and maintenance by the (1) I shall first consider the defendant of an alleged dangerous platform or "walk" leading from a question ax to whether the defendant ink stairway of defendant's. pre-was in full possession and contract of that part of the premises where mises to a window, and thence by a the accident occurred, and as to wooden bridge to an adjoining build. whether the plaintiff? was using the oF godown in which the job print. same at the time of the accident presses and certain offices of! the defendant were located, in the regular course of business, or upon the invitation of the It is alleged in the complaint that defendant, this plank walk was a dangerous From the findings of fact herein construction, in that it was not before made, it seems to me that protected by a railing or guard of} the defendant at the time of the some sort along the side which was accident was clearly in full charge immediately over the stairway, and and control of the passage a that the window or opening to which platform and the doorway which was it led, for the purpose of reaching, being used as on means of the wooden bridge connecting the communication between its generat buildings, was not of sufficient heigh' office at No, 14 Kiukiang Road, and to enable a person of ordinary the office of its superinténdant stature to pass through the opening Job printing in the godown building, to the connecting bridge with safety.

This platform had boon erected It is the claim of the plaintiff that} the special instance and request the absence of a protecting railing of defendant's superintendent, for along the walk or passageway, and the accommodation of, and in order the low opening or window at the to fucllitato the transaction of the Jend of the passageway, constituted business of the defendant between in and of themselves a dangerous its two offices. While the cost of construction, the maintenance of; the construction of this platform which by the defendant for the use was borne by the Ezra estate, it of its employees nnd the general Was authorized, by Mr, Sopher, who public amounted to negligence per se, Was not only the manager of the and for which the defendant would Edward Ezra estate, but was also be liable in ease of accident without the managing director of the fault or negligence on the part of defendant company, It is true that the person using the same, this back stairway was used by the servants and employees of other The Defence tenants in the building, who were The defendant alleges in its an-occupying the first and third floors, swer, that this platform, and door-but this particular platform and jway which the pluintift claims was opening on to the wooden bridge, the eauise of the accident, were not was designed expressly for the ace constructed or maintained by the commodation and use of the defendant, and that the defendant defendant company, Under suet hud no control or supervision over circumstances, it is dificult to escap same, either before or at the the conclusion that this platform time of the accident in question. I: Passageway was not at all times is also alleged in the answer that ud control of the this platform and doorway were constructed and The Question of Trespass The next question of fact to be decided, is whether the pi uusinge this platform 0 said estate had possession, control fon the day of the for the sand supervision of said purpose of reaching the adjoining. doorway at all times mentioned in the godown, wax doing so upon. the complaint, "It is further alleged in invitation of the defendant, either: the answer that this platform and express or implied, or whether doorway were not intended for the way licensed or a mere treepasse: use of the general public, and that as claimed by the defendant the plaintiff' in using the same at Tt must be conceded that on the time of the accident, was a trespasser and had no right or invitation day of the accident the plaintiff to use or go upon that part of its wus expressly invited by. premises. "And fi is claimed suporintendant of defendant's luting department to visit its Unt the phaintit self guilty offices at No, 14 Kiukiang Road on of nesice this platform for the purpose of a matter of lnwiness, but ib is the job printing establish contended by the defendant that ment of the defendant located in the such invitation to the plaintitt was Timited and cent auljoining godown, and that such eon-andi that tributary negligence on the part of the plaintiff should bar a recovery to pass thevazh the rene corvidys and go upon this platform fter dealing with the findings of Passageway for the purpose of, nct, the judgment goes on to Visiting the office of the superin Tt' is a well recognized principle dant in the godown building, of that a lessee of premises, who that when he attempted so ty da is in full possession and control, he became a mere trespasser, 89 far owes a duty to third persons re-/a* entering upon sorting thereto in the course. of defendant's premise business oF upon his invitation, either|and that the pi express or implied, to Keep his pre-not liable for the damage mises in a reasonably safe condition, stained in falling. from and he will be held liable for injuries platform, resulting to such third persons from Now I have found from tie the defective condition of repairs evidence that for long time prive the premises. to this accident, when people called The defendant herein was undoubtedly the lessee of the premises) at No. 1 Kiukianz Road, at the offices of the "China Dress upon which this accident oecurre', purpose of having jab' printing tut denies liability upon several work done for them, that i: was grounds.

Ist—It is contended thatthe custom and practice for the it is not shown by the evidence that! officers and employees of the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account