The Archive · 1926

Chinese Chamber of Commerce

July 22, Witxour entering into person-ties or expressing any opinion as to the present or previous officers of the Chinese General Chamber of Commerce, comment] may be made on the broader} political implications of the election controversy which has} at last spent itself. Democracy fs not only a political doctrine of popular control of government; it is even more a political Imethod, a system of ce-ordinating and articulating mass opinion so that the majority shall rule without destroying or endangering! basic rights of the minority. Wher democracy, as a political system, functions unchecked, there is anarchy. Therefore, in all truly democratic countries, checks and balances have been created for the purpose of protecting the whole political system from sudden and destructive changes and for providing the minority with a voice and al [protection from oppression. Such!

complicated political structure does not arise in a day nor is it} the rule that a system which works admirably in one country' will do as well in another. For instance, Britons regard their King and Parliament as representing a fine type of democratic government, while Americans look with equal pride upon a system which has no King but which provides three veto possibilities, the second house, the executive and the judiciary.

Democratic forms have never been successful when suddenly' thrust upon a people. They have been most advantageously utilize Jed when they have been the results of slow and steady growth, principally among the economic middle class. Thus, British democracy and American democracy go back to Magna Carta through the Cromwellian Revolution, the political reforms of the early Georges, colonial expansion, the rise of the economic middle class as a result of the industrial revolution and finally, in the United States, ithe American revolution with its concomitant struggle _between the Federal Government and the States ending in a terrific civil }war, Democratic forms lie more in the consciousness of the! people who sense them from tradition than as a result of philosophers and written constitutions, Thus, in the United States, the practice of polities and the every-day decisions of the Supreme Court have done more to provide the protections Jand balances necessary in a democratic state than the writ ings of Thomas Jefferson and the propaganda of the French Revolution, Now, we must take it that this long experience in democratic forms is altogether foreign to China, It is to be admitted that in their private life, the Chinese fare democratic, there being no landed or hereditary aristocracy; it is also to be noted that the communistic family system of] China is democratic, there being, no large independent property-owners and the popular control of family decisions being, except, Jas modified by a wholesome respect for the aged, democratic. But this democracy has never found a political expression and therefore has not developed political method, Thus, the voting for parliamentarians been futile, as the people could not understand their interests in the matter and had little faith in the result. Similarly, the parliamentary technique within the Parliament was far from anything that could be tolerated, say in the British House of Commons. In the organization of societies and committees, in the! preparation of public meetings, in the working out of popular resolutions, the Chinesp seem to have a confusion of forms and methods, which usually results in some aggressive individual putting forward his own plan and method and all the others follo\ ing at the time and complaining fon the morrow. Now, one of the most time-honoured' rules of] democratic procedure is to make a row before the vote, but, to accept unqualifiedly the decision after the vote has once been' taken.

In the recent election of the Chinese General Chamber of] Commerce, certain candidates! presented themselves and were elected. The election was contested after the voting had been completed on the ground that the method of voting was improper. This should, of course, have been brought before the scrutineers prior to the election or at the time, but was, in fact, only discussed after it had been seen that, the votes were cast in such a manner as to make one party of Shanghai Chinese dominant in the Chamber, leaving practically no voice to any minority, even' when that minority represented, as was claimed, the major Chinese interests of the place. Following the general elections, there were wide protests to many Chinese authorities, some of whom had, under the charter of {thie Chamber, a voice; but others were altogether outside their province either in. listening to appeals or expressing an opinion. It was none of their business in democratic system. Everybody having expressed himself freely fon the subject, the Committee went into session and elected new officers, among them a Chairman. He promptly announced his intention of not serving, whereupon his decision was not accept= ed, even after he had thrice re~ fused the crown, but a long series of negotiations was entered upon, to save everybody's face. Meanwhile, the minority and their friends are sabotaging the Chamber and the new officers to show that there can be no sucjeessful functioning as long as the Chamber represents only one political party. What the end of it all will be, we do not know Jand do not particularly care, a8 it is strictly a Chinese matter in no way directly affecting foreign interests, It is, however, of importance to foreigners to note that much of the fuss in the Chamber can be explained very simply: they did not know how to go about it. They wasted time and energy and thought and finally fell back on "face-saving"" devices, which is exactly what happens in Peking every day to the destruction of China and the utter confusion of all foreigners.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account