The Archive · 1926

Chinese Practitioners' Point of View

The Chinese Bar Association and the Federation of College Faculties at Shanghai have issued the follow. ing statement on the matter of th rendition of the Mixed Court.

'So many of the misleading reports ang inaccurate statements in regard to the rendition of the Mixed Court have appeared during the last few Gays in the local foreign press that' we as representatives of the Chinese Legal profession, or being otherwise interested in the question, consider it opportune to place before the public what we think issue.

First of all we deprecate the heat as shown by the foreign leal fraternity in their discussion of the alleged, settlement of the principal" points between the Chinese officials and the, Consular Body, concerning the restoration of the Mixed Court to Chinese control. No heated diseussion of so important a question would be Becoming of persons with a thorough legal training; such involves loss of dignity to the legal profession, with which are always associated' impartiality and cool-hended must be pointed out that the! rendition of the Mixed Court to China was, decided years ago ant cannot be longer deferred with iously injuring the friendly rela~ pionship between China and. the! Foreign Powers. For 15 yea Chinese have been urging the return of the court, and everybody knows that the failure to of tion constitutes a grievance. Fortunately, and enlightened foreign: claim and realizing the necessity of conceding it, have been supporting the negotiations looking forward to the settlement of the question. Tt is hoped that the negotiations will soon be concluded so that from the whole community, both foreign and Chinese, one cause for friction between them may be removed.

Much Astonishment Caused Unfortunately the Far Eastern American Bar Association of Shang. hai saw fit to issue a statement to Court is too obvious to mention. But the ques tion which confronts us to-day is; are we going to conserve the interests of about 100 foreign lawyer of justice and at the expense of the friendly relationship Between Chinese and foreigners in the whole of China generally and those at Shanghai in particular? America's friendship for China is now put to atest. In the past thera has ben much manifestation of it, but the fact that the American Judiciat authorities have allowed the foreign lawyers to use their court room as the meeting place to discuss plans of opposition to the rendition of the Mixed Court which has been under consideration between the Chinese officials and the foreign consular officials including—the American Consul-General is rather; significant indeed. The use of the American court room with the pé mission of the Judge for such poses may easily be construed as an interference of the judiciary with the functions of the American executive—the American Consul-General in the present case—but that is for the American Senate to say; the Chinese Government should, however, take note of the fact, Irrelevant Arguments Some of the cases cited in the statement of the American Bar Association and other statements to show the undesivability of the rendition of the Court at the present moment, it must be pointed out, are! relevant and the conditions under which the other cases as cited had happened do not exist to-day. If we argue in favour of the restoration of the Mixed Court along the same irrelevatit lines, we may niention, to show. that' "honesty is the best; policy" is not always observed among. foreign officials, the case of the alleged embezzlement by the U. Court Clerk, William A, Chapman and that of Earl B, Rose which were ported in the semi issue of the China Press" in which the foreign wwyers made an attack on the integrity of Chinese officials, ete, \There are many such cases' that could be cited, but, as we maintain, they are irrelevant.

In regard to the feared restoration of corporal punishment, and the introduction of other abuses, upon the rendition of the Mixed Court, the existing Chinese Code renders {this impossible. Tt weald be simple to cite the lynching of negroes in wriea or the failure to enforce the dry law strictly in that country as proving that the administration of law in America ig ndt rvithout fault, The citing of exceptional cases, however, proves nothing and unworthy of the lofty and digni-fed attitude that legally trained men should adopt whether they be Chinese or foreign, The argument that the presence of foreign lawyers in the Mixed Court would render the court]

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account