The Archive · 1923

A Political Break

May 28.

THE whole course of Chinese history since the revolution of 1911, and the present deplorable condition of the country, cannot but make thoughtful observers question whether the democratic _torm of government which Chine has borrowed from the West voets the peculiar no is of the people. Rebellion, official corrupt tion and inefficiency, robbery, and other forms of lawlessness among high and low, have been common at all times; but never before, so far as we know, has a new government expressly formed for the purpose of introducing better laws and methods of goverment been so quickly paralyzed by prevailing lawlessness. In excuse it may be said that democracy has been tried only for a few years, and that it takes a very long time for a nation so large and illiterate to understand and assimilate democratic ideals. But there is no sign anywhere of the slightest progress in this direction. The changes that have occurred seem to be entirely on the surface; beneath, the current of life, thought, and custom, flows on as it always has flowed. The political importation has not taken root; whatever the future may bring, the experiment of the last twelve years, so far, has been a dismal failure.

Opinions may vary as to what is the fundamental cause of this failure. In our judgment it is very plain. When the Manchu dynasty was overthrown and the new government formed, too great a break was made with the past; in the political changes no connexion was made or left between the old and the new. The warnings of history on this point are old and familiar, and it is strange how often they are either forgotten or ignored. Reformers must come to terms with the traditions, the habits, the common feelings and interests, even the prejudices, which stand rooted in the national character. For the heritage of the past with its political, social and religious institutions is an embodiment of the national education and experience. To Edmund Parke, one of the greatest of English political thinkers, there was always an element of wonder, of mystery, in political and social development, as if there was a power at work more than human in the cohesion of men in societies, in political obedience, in the sanctity of contract, in all the fabric of law and charter and obligation which is the sheltering bulwark between civilization and barbarism. Hence he dreaded all political changes; he could not bear to see a finger laid upon a single stone of a single political edifice. So intense a reverence for the past may easily become an obstacle to all change and progress. But the Chinese in their recent revolution went to the other extreme.

Among a people intensely conservative, moulded by custom and tradition into a rigid uniformity greater than that of any other nation, the attempt was made by a small minority to break utterly with the past. The government was overturned; officials were changed; youth with its enthusiasm but without experience came to the front; men of age and wisdom were put on one side; reverence for the teachings of the Chinese sages disappeared; social customs were assailed; even the national costume was changed. Tt was almost as if the crew of a ship cast away its anchors, changed its officers for ignorant, incompetent seamen, destroyed the charts, damaged the compass and steering apparatus, and then expected to voyage safely through unknown and stormy seas to an unknown destination.

The history of the American revolution of 1776, which influenced so powerfully the student leaders of the Chinese revolution, cannot be cited us disproving the argument. All that occurred then was the sundering of a political tie which had already become weak. The life of the American people, whether in New England or in Virginia, remained the same after as before the Revolution; there was no genera! overturning. The French Revolution of 1789 did not last and ended in the rise of a Napoleon to power partly because the changes it made were too violent. Cromwell's Republic, 1649-1660, failed because it was never able to take root; the Protector had never won the whole-hearted support of_ the church, ths aristocracy, the landed gentry, or the sympathy of the great mass of the nation. What has occurred in Russia during the past few years is a frightful illustration of the mistake of suddenly attempting to change the whole course of the life of a great nation. Perhaps much of the resentment now felt against foreigners by the Chinese is due to their disappointment with foreign political institutions from the adoption of which so much material prosperity and power was expected. For this mistake the Chinese can blame no one but al themselves.

It is not for strangers, however friendly, to dictate to the Chinese people What the form of their\ government ought to be; it is for them to work out their own political salvation. It is permissible, however, to urge that if ever a fresh start is made, whatever is good in their past, whatever has given continuity to their history during the centuries when other nations have risen, flourished and then declined, should be conserved. In other words, whatever form of government is adopted should be entirely in harmony with the ethos or spirit of the people, therefore peculiarly adapted to their requirements. Where the old social order needs changing, let the changes be made gradually and slowly, as in England, where law and custom broaden slowly down from precedent to precedent. And it may be added that to-day England is the mo t truly democratic country in the world.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account