The second issue at stake, Sir, the prevention of similar outrages in future is at the moment less immediately pressing, but it is an issue so wide that with it is bound up the future of foreign security in China, the future of commerce in China, the future of China herself. And what are the alternatives?
There is first what might be called the Russellian theory which perpetrated the amazing inconsistency that though Nationalism and Patriotism—in the more vigorous countries of the West—aro stated to be the greatest curses of mankind, the preservation of Nationalist and independent Sovereignty in China is to be regarded as_ the sole hope of future human happiness. The holders of this theory, as also most of the elements which constitute Yang China" argue that China is striving to adapt her ancient digestive organs to the political pabulum of the modern world, and suggest that every sympathy must be shown to her in the resulting period of chronic political dyspepsia.
In other words whether the present chaos lasts ten or a hundred years, whether it remains'as it is to-day or becomes even-infinitely worse, whether brigands dominate the country and foreigners have to flee from it, China must be allowed to go her own way, to solve her own problem—and incidentally in the meantime to ruin her own and foreign trade—without any interference from outside.
This was the theory which was to great extent acted upon—though perhaps not very genuinely believed in—at the Washington Conference. It was in the nature of a great gamble that by assuming China to be more "'advanced" than she really was, she would rise to the occasion and show herself to be "advanced." The gamble has not come off. China has signally failed to rise to the occasion.
There is another theory, that China has reached the last stage before complete disintegration That her ancient art is dead, her once splendid literature reduced to pornography, the high obligation st Government prostituted to personal profit, no religion, no ethics, no honesty, not even "face," but rottenness and corruption though and through to the core, without hope of "self-salvation, without hope of self-respect, a vast but untidy remnant of the Old world fit only for the dust-bin of the New. And the answer to that theory is foreign intervention, partition, and the end of China's sovereign rights.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.