The Archive · 1923

Counsel for Defence

Addressing the jury on behalf of accused, M Lipson Ward spoke of the serious nature of the charge and said it. was) only by the m of God that this was not a t for murder. The case for the Crown, which rested on the evidence of Bakhar Singh alone, was an elaborate structure without foundation. Mrs. Davis was not charged as being a party to the crime, but it had been suggested that she was a party to it, although no evidence had been offered of any concerted purpose between the accused and herself. The prosecution had not dared to say this openly, otherwise Mrs. Davis would have gone into the dock. Proceeding, counsel dwelt upon important discrepancies in the complainant's story, espe: ly upon his statement made hospital, and afterwards tradicted in court, that the two women ran when the attack on him began. Counsel commented upon the delay in taking proceedings against the accused, making difficult for herself and her witnesses to recall what took place on that particular date, and also unau the prosecution's method of identification. Coming to the alibi, counsel suggested that the witnesses differing in points of detail was proof of its truth. If the story had been concocted, cused would have come into court with " carefully prepared story, a cast iron alibi, and world have arranged to call witnesses who could give convincing proof that she was elsewhere at but counsel asked the j ay that her witnesss were reliable people who would net perjure themselves the interests of a friend. Ther were so many absurdities in the complainant's that counsel asked the jury to—conclude. that not only would? it be unsafe to convict on such evidence, but that they were satisiicd that, whoever committed this _ahominable crime, it was net Mrs. Ro-warth, That there might he suspicion, suggestion, possibility or probability of guilt was not enough. There must be certainty. It was obvious that. the people who attacked complainant, intend ed to kill him. Was it possible that. this woman of over 60 took part in such a horrible crime?

THE CROWN ADVOCATE, In summing up for the prosecution, the Crown Advocate said that, under the charge of aiding and abetting, the accused was made a principal in the second deg: There had never been suggestion that com-lamont had not told the truth as he knew it, and the defence was reduced to the well-worn plea that he was suffering from shock at the time he told his story, and that his mind was affected. The presecution had suggested no explanation why complainant sheld have lighted on Mrs. Rowarth, against: whom he had no animus. There was no doubt that he had been decoyed, but he was never asked by the defence whether he. had any private appointment on this particular ning, Whether he was concerned in any religious trouble or whether he had quarrelled with any of his friends among the money lenders. Nor had it been suggested that he had been taken to this place for any or other purpose than to he paid a debt owing to him, As to the suggestion that a plan to decoy would have been secretly carried out, the safest way to commit a crime was to commit it naturally. Commenting on the incident of the lighted lamp ecarried by the amah, counsel suggested it was obviously intended to be a signal to those in waiting.

As to the a/ibi counsel suggested that all it came to was this: that accused was at Mrs. Davis's house in the afternoon, and at dinner, and that she afterwards went to the cinema, but there had been no evidence to show that in that rather crowded party she could not have been out. for an hour and a half without her absence being noted.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account