uly 29.
Tue British reply to Mr. Eugene Chen's attempt to justify, the Canton boycott of Hongkong) is altogether "so express and admirable" that it leaves very' little to be said. But there are one or two i's to be dotted and "t's" to be crossed, one or two Points of intention, which the man who wrote the' reply could hardly include in his document, although they cannot have! escaped his noric But the} public must not be left in any} doubt about them.
Mr. Chen's attempt to twist the meaning of Sir James Jamieson's letter of June 22 to Dr. C. C. Wu might be called childish, except that.we should not like to accuse any child of such a piece of artifice. Sir James Jamieson's meaning was perfectly plain, There were strong rumours of an impending attack on Shameen and wealthy Cantonese were fleeing' to Hongkong; there were also rumours that some of the! students meant deliberately to commit martyrdom in order accentuate feeling against the British—possibly untrue and yet, considering the pitch of frenzy, to which students can work themselves up, not absolutely unbelievable. At any rate, in view of all circumstances, Sir James felt it his duty to fe and tell Dr. Wu that, if any trouble occurred on the 28rd, it would be because Chinese began it and the responsibility would be wholly on Dr. Wu's Government. "Nothing could be plainer, especially remembering all that happened since May 30 and in view of which the people in Shameen would certainly not have fired had it not been necessary nor have gone on shooting a moment longer than they must.
The British statement quite rightly takes up Mr. Eugene Chen's attempt to minimize the! question of who fired the first] shot as point of secondary] importance" and "not a capital issue." But My. Chen's secret] motive in making these extraordinary assertions should be Shown up. Up to this point the Canton Government had always maintained that the British in Shameen (nothing ever being Sti about other nationalities, Moh it was actually. the French who- first replied to the Chinese assault) fired unprovoked upon a sion of harmless The even held a sort of inquiry and published a report, with illustrations, many} of which were strongly suspected of being fakes; to uphold the sane argument. Why then this sudden volte-face? Was it not in anticipation that Hongkong would never accede to the Canton demands and Canton would then say: "See how hopeless it is ito deal with the imperialists'; see how reasonable we are, our-we are even willing not 13 the matter of the unprovoked attack on the Shakee procession and to assume for} the purposes of negotiation that there may be some doubt as to who fired first. Can we be blamed if the negotiations have broken down and if our people in their indignation press on the boycott?"
No impartial person will dispute the British statement's description of Mr, Chen's composition as "a desperate attempt to' find an excuse for the institution and maintenance of the! boycott." But it is really much more than that, Mr. Chen must, if possible, get something out of the British delegates. They have factually been induced to come and negotiate, although the proper way to deal with the boy feot would have been to impose that blockade which Hongkong is falsely accused of instituting. Therefore Mr. Chen pursues the tactics of an old-clothes dealer} who begins by asking ten times Jas much as he is privately willing to accept. With every artifice of which he is capable—and no one will do Mr. Chen the injustice of saying they are few—he proceeds to pile up a case. The more he can appear to excuse of yesterday, the more he may seem to be' justified in asking to-morrow. "And always there is that possibility to be guarded against that the negotiations may fail, and that the British must be made to appear the culprits, so that what it has been impossible to wring out of Hongkong by fair means the! strike and boycott committees shall be deputed to extract by foul.
The Cantonese tactics are s0 obvious, so familiar, so discouraging, that one might almost wonder how the conference survived the receipt of this first statement: except, we suppose, that the British delegates, having taken the trouble to come to Canton, felt that they must at any rate hear if Mr. Chen|i had any proposal to make which they could take back to Hongkong. But there is only one thing that Canton wants, namely, a loan, The Northern expedition must be financed; and the Cantonese business people have been so heavily taxed, so much damaged by the boycott, so much squeezed by the strike committee, that even their patience might be exhausted with further demands. Besides, think how attractively a loan from Hongkong could be represented in the Chinese papers as, an indemnity! For these reasons it appears most unlikely that the Canton Government would accept a loan such as the British suggest, to be devoted to really constructive work under British supervision. If they do accept, it will be with a firm determination to burke the supervision and repudiate the liability, as soon as the money is in their coffers.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.