The Archive · 1923

Four Volumes. Longmans

Collecting Andrew Long was one Gigmy earliest literary habits. There was nothing quite like it then: there is nothing like it possible to the book-lover of today. There are, of course, authors whose books are fascinat~ ingly different—Mr. Belloc, Mr. Baring, Mr. Chesterton are all pleasantly various, but their variety is not quite so rich as_ -Lang's was. Ju collecting Long, I collected litera~ ture—there was an extreme charm, only to be understood by! the bibliomaniac, in ranging "The Mark of Cain" beside "Homeric Hymns," or the "History of Scotland" beside "Ballades in Blue China'? and "Essays in Little," or "Helen of Troy" next to Myth, Ritual and Religion." And to read them—~ for I could and can read anything by him—always to find, behind totem, villanelle, essay or story, the same Andrew Long, whimsical, opinionated, scholarly, and, unless you were one of those unfortunates who did not like his manner, incomparably charming.

Nowhere did Long so express his character, so give himself away, as in his poetry. It is the fashion to despise '"'literary'" poetry to-day. We murmur "ex-excise," when we are confronted with such poems as "Pisidice'! or "How the Maid Marched' from Blois'—and yet I wonder. No doubt Long's poetry is of the study. No doubt it owes much to his reading, much to echoes of other poets. His world was largely a world of books. All that may be admitted; but there is a fragrance, a sweetness, and a. deft craftsmanship about this manner which still charm me,' with my ears full of very different music.

No one would claim for Long a place beside the great or the inspired poets of our Jiterature:! but if other than the greatest and most necessary poets are to write verse, is it not better that they should have this manner than some later fashions? Are taste, scholarship, reading, restraint, experience, breadth of interest all necessarily inimical to poetry 1 am no cricketer, and have ply -watched trout—but I am ready to believe that cricket and fishing are quite as good stuff for poetry: as a pattern of gamboge kittens against a scarlet complex. Where so much modern poetry gives you nothing but accounts of emotional reactions of doubtful value, Long's poetry gives you intellectual amusement. Take him, j for instance. at his most frivolous—the Emersonian.parody, "Brahma If the wild bowler thinks he bowls, if the batsman thinks he's bowled, They know nct, poor, misguided souls, They too shall perish unconsoled, I am the batsman and the bat.

I am the bowler and the ball, The empire. the pavilion cat, The roller, pitch and all.

Long began writing verse when many—the Pact Laureate, Mr. Gosse, Mr. Dobson, Henley, Madame Duclaux—were xperimenting with old French forms. I do not know that Long ever produced in any of these forms a! poem as certain of immortality! as Dr. Bridges' triolet, When! first we met;" but he is, withi Dobson, the chief of the ballade-makers. He could do what he liked with the form—varying and lightening it, or occasionally using it for graver and more solemn exacts, as in the "Ballads of Sleep" and "of Dream."

He could be extremely enthu-+ siastic, and extremely scornful—witness his devotion to Joan of Are, his anger at the higher criticism of Homer, or his lines on the Shelley Society, with their bland, vitriolic refrain Dr. Furnivall: "For Shelley' was the Doctor's father's friend." He was at his best an admirable translator—his versions of poets of the Greek Anthology remain evidence that, before thd Chinese poets were familiar td our versifiers, the Greeks gave us cameos scarcely less exquisite to frame. His poems about bookd and authors are inimitable: whe+ ther appreciative, as in thd rhymed review of Austin Dobson, or humorously fanciful as' inf "The Journey of the Heroes," with its glorious ending when! Porthos stabs fatally David Grieve in the battle where Zola's ragged regiment comes, with dynamite in hand, And Flaubert's crew of country doctors devastate the land.

On Robert Elsmere Friar Tuck falls with his quarter-staff.

Nom Dz! to see the clerics fight.

might make the sourest laugh It was Romance Long wor+ shipped. I do not claim that she! is the greatest goddess—but im reading these poems again and realizes that there are far les# desirable deities—"Daily News."

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account