The Archive · 1926

Fatal Error of Expanding

This means that a big army, spread over a huge area criminally wasteful futility. To exe pand and spread over the country is to weaken at the centre. To, delegate authority to commanders in remote places is to raise up potential enemies and invite betrayal and defeat, Wu Pei-fu was a great success as a conqueror while he moved with what seemed a pitifully small army under his immediate personal control, The wider he attempted to spread his authority, and his operations and the more he tried to do with overwhelmingly big hordes of undisciplined troops, rely ing upon subordinates and allies for their discipline and control, the ess he accomplished in his scheme lof reunification and the greater the burden of his operations upon the country became. Foreign military observers are as certain that China cannot be reunited by force by such tactics at the rest of us are that she cannot be reunited by cone ference and the barter of reason. But no Chinese general seems eap-Jable of seeing it. Each one who rises, through the efficient handling of a' small compact force, into the warlord class, falls into the same fatal error of thinking that by: increasing the number of his retainers and the breadth of his dependencies Jecographically, he is increasing his strength, Six years ago when Wu Peisfa and his victorious 3rd Division first established themselves at Loyang, Marshal Wa told the writer that ho did not believe in big armies, but in intensive training and better equipment. He said that while China might easily afford an armed rabble of two or three millions, she could not possibly equip and train a really efficient modern army of more than 200,000.

1 do not think' that Wu Pei-fa ever made a public statement which inspired more hope for him in foreign military experts than this lone. It seemed that he had grasped the one idea essential to the conquest of China by a Chinese, A Fundamental Truth Lost seems now that he has com pletely lost his grasp upon this fundamental truth, At Shanhaic oan the folly of assembling a heterogeneous horde of 200,000 men of unequal training and unequal rehiabitity and starting them all forfard on a Tine so broad that it was impossible to keep essential communications open was amply. demonstrated. Even before Feng Yusiang's defection, nothing " ever happened worth recording except at that particular point, of the line that Wu was personally inspecting. When he went away for 48 hours on the Haichi to inspect. the coast beyond Shanhaikuan, the whole organization disintegrated like a mat shed ina gale. From this experience he seems to have learned yething, nor has any other com mander learned anything. Even the Kuominchun is too big and not fas compact as it ought to be because Feng Vu-hsiang was led away from the vight idea of hav. ing a small, highly trained and well equipped fore by the same. silly ambition and exposed himself to Ganger by adopting inferior units into. his organization and by de~ legating authority to subordinates in, remote positions.

Sun Ch'van-fang is a strong and stable man, but he delights. now in. territorial expansion and the adoption into his army of units whose commanders see a temporary jsdvantage in. joining hin, but who have no, good reason to. be genuine-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account