The Archive · 1926

Other Fatal Defects

Quite apart from these ultramodern trappings, every foreign military expert knows that a Chinese farmy in the field against a real business-like force would display several fatal weaknesses which would mean certain defeat in spite of the best killing equipment and training in its use. 'The most efficient 'Chinese army in this country has no transport service of its own and no medical or sanitary service worthy'

the name." "All transport is impressed, and when an army eaters Chinese community it becomes the business of every owner of a boat, heart, mule, donkey, wheelbarrow, pushcart, or, in modernized communies, a motor car, to get it out of sight and keep it hidden. No force [can be moved faster than the essential transport can be hounded out of its hiding places and prodded into service. 'The more the danger to the means of locomotion, these being the capital investment of poor people, the greater the reluctance and the' slower the pace. This is one reason that Chinese armies in action follow the railways so closely and it is because the Chinese armies have few persons who are really expert in railway transport that a month's occupation of a railway by the military means a 20 per cent. reduction in the line's efficiency. Here is displayed what would be a vital weakness in a modernly conducted wat The "Medical" Service As for the medical service, the less [said the better. When one talks of disbandment now to a Chinese officer, he is very pat with his reply that if recruiting were discouraged for a few years there would be no army to disband. In barracks, it is said (for there are no statistics), the death rate from disease and accident fs ten per pent. per annum, In the field tetanus accounts for ten per leant. of all wounded. Exposure and neglect account for 100 per cent, fof all seriously wounded; and there fare probably very few who ate badly wounded and ever dream of returning to the ranks. During the fighting between the Kuominchan and Li Ching-lin last December, the perjeentage of those wounded in the fehest and abdomen who arrived at! fa rear-line dressing station, was twiting. They could not craw! that far so they died at the end of their do not think that any feature of Feng Vu-hsiang's campaigns ever made his Christianity seem so thin' 1 veneer as the preparations that he made for the care of wounded last, December when 4000 men who contrived to get back to Peking, after days of neglect and agony, were thrown entirely: u imierey and charity of the foreign medical com-Some of his missionary Sponsors should have seen his men coming in here with broken legs, splinties and untended, lying on the steel bottoms of steel' trucks with the thermometer at 20 F., and then have seen them rolled "out into ice has with their broken legs dangling, five days after they beet shattered by shrapnel, tobe bounced off to Nanyuan, seven miles away and turned over to the foreign volunteer surgeon. Yet the Kuomin chun medical service was considered a model unit, much advertise fed by the pious. What goes on in units that do not even pretend to modernism after a battle T have seen too often and do not care to describe, The point here is that it does not make for either efficiency or morale fond is a vital weakness in even the best Chinese units.

The Necessary Purge Such then is the Chinese army under the supreme—militarists Obviously the way to conquer China is to organize a very small unit, well paid, well-equipped in every modern and with some respectable objective to present to the men, and lead it forth, keeping it a compact' body and recognizing no allies. It would cost more to equip and train two Chinese divisions according to Occidental standards than it does to equip 20 divisions of the sort of riff. aff that the average Chinese general would review with pride, but their burden upon the country-side would be nothing and, in action, they would conatitat such a cheap and thorough filer history, The greatest cost ge as China has never taken in

to an efficient Chinese unit of 20, or 30, or 40 thousand men, in a wat to end war, would be for shoe leather and instep supporters worn out in the long trek after an enemy that won't stand and fight.

To return to this campaign in the north:—the strategy of the high commanders on the "allied" side has been subject to severe foreign criticism ever since the Kuominchun evacuated Peking. It is not the neutral foreigner's business to tell any one Chinese group how to get the best of another and no Chinese "Marshal" could be expected to accept foreign advice even though they had paid for it, since the least of them will tell you that Na-plun (Napoleon) was a tyro and would have' got'owhere-in China, This being the ease it isn't really unneutral to lump foreign military opinion here and: quote it, What Kuominchun Might Do First of all, we assume that the Kuominchun enjoys a. unified command and has the benefit of Red Russian expert direction. Against besieged army of 120,000 under a [single staff, no one would move dozen hap-hazard expeditions along various converging routes unless he had the most perfect system for timing the movements of each-through the most perfect staff work, jand coordination, To move a dozen weak columns against. one, strong. Jenemy when the latter has all the, Jadvantage of short inner lines. of Jcommunication and a perfect organization is simply to invite him to pick them off one at a time and annihilate them individually at his leisure. If your movements are perfectly synchronized and you can be, Jabsolutely sure that every one of your dozen feeble columns is going. to function as an attacking force at the same moment you certainly have, the advantage in that you force the besieged enemy to split his force into 12 and you stand a very good chance of confusing him and making. him expose weaknesses in his armour. The "allies" from the very: beginning have demonstrated, 80 clearly that the riesha coolies laugh about it, that they have no star work, no coordination, no possible [chance of synchronizing their attack, Their movements have been timed in the worst possible fashion and our opinion of the Kuominchun leaders Jand their Russian experts is much lowered by the fact that they have not registered a much—more thorough, smashing defeat upon the various puny expeditions as they ventured through the hills, Their retorts prove them as weak as did their medical service last December.

Obviously the way to dislodge the Kuominchun is through the instru-sion into their country of a single heavy force, pushing forward while little auxiliary forees which have previously fortified themselves strongly, hold the avenues of escape. [Nankow is not the ideal single line the Chinese themselves have recognized ever since the Feng~ ies went head-long in that direction in April; but there are many other obvious routes upon which an overwhelmingly big army could be moved with crushing effect, the officers knew how to do it and the army were worth moving.

At the present juncture, however, i€would take a lot more than perfect strategy to help the alleged armies involved to make more of their posi tions, one way or another, and the outcome of the war cannot mean much to the foreigner unless happens to get in the way of a tidal retreat.

This is Self Determination The moral of this review is pro-ably much too obvious to be popular with Chinese readers. The reunification of China, the disbandment of nearly two million superfluous and expensive soldiers, the restoration fof pence and order, the return of the country to some degree of productivity, would be absurdly easy as an internal reform if there were a ingle Chinese militarist who could grasp the problem and execute it—Which there isn't. It would be no more than an easy tactical exercise for some hundreds of Occidental division commanders, anyone of whom would be glad to undertake it if the Powers would give him carte Uianehe and a fair start—which they won't. Instead we go in the good fold way, watching the show that the Chinese' people pay for with thei life blood, being crowded out of the back seats that we have paid for with three centuries' enterprise, into the aisles marked "standing room only," and all of us voting it a thoroughly rotten show at best—but, very one shouting out between act Isn't it an inspiring show of pro~ gress! Isn't it wonderful what this liable old civilization has brought forth under new conditions! Just fsee them waste T.N-T. and then say they're not our equals! Hear the women shriek and watch the flames rise and tell me that they are not working out their own salvation! Hands off, I say, this is self-determination!"

Priest Passenger: "What do you suppose makes the ship roll so? Itt the death of me!" 11 senger (furiously): "It's that' im~ beetle of an officer up there.": He does nothing but walk from one side: of the ship to the other... It's enough to capsize the-vessel"".! anes

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account