The Archive · 1920

Motorists and the Outside Roads

Sept. 11.

Tue reluctant decision of Mr. G. W, King, H. M. Police Magistrate, in the case where a British subject was summoned for alleged contravention of the municipal traffic by-laws, by furiously driving a motor-car on North Szechuen Road Extension, raises a very debatable point. We believe it to be a correct interpretation of the decision to say that Mr. King's ruling was that the Land Regulations, by virtue of Land Regulation No. 1, apply only to the area defined therein, and that the road in question, being outside those limits, does not come within the jurisdiction of ihe municipal by-laws. If such indeed be the case, it follows that mone of the municipal by-laws apply to municipal roads running beyond the borders of the Settlement: that they, are in fact ultra vires thei Municipal Council under their own charter. There is some \field Road—outside the Settle-lose, for the property is foreignment—which was held to be within the limits. So far as we know the point has never been taken to a higher court and consequently may be said to be still definitely undecided.

There can be no doubt that under Land Regulation No. 1 the application of the by-laws has been strictly limited, but another aspect to the question is given by the consideration of a portion of Regulation VI, which says It shall also be lawful for the Land Renters, and others who may be entitled to vote as hereinafter mentioned, in public meeting assembled, to purchase land leading or being out of the Settlement, or to accept land from foreign or native owners upon terms to be mutually agreed upon between the Council and such foreign or native owners for the purpose of converting the same into roads or public gardens and places of recreation and amusement, ete.

It_may very well be argued that No. VI by implication extends the operation wf the Land Regulations, and all legislation deriving authority therefrom, beyond the limits set forth in Re-\gulation No. 1; that, with power to purchase and maintain, the; Council has power to control the users of such acquired land. It does not seem an unreasonable contention, for it merely serves to" extend a definition clause. owned. Is municipally, acquired land, therefore, to be under no legislative control? The question has but to be asked to be answered. Yet if Mr. King's decision' is correct, there are no by-laws operating in territory bought by. the community outside the Settlement.

The extreme importance of the question which has now been raised is easily seen. The prospect of traffic offences being committed with impunity outside settlement limits is at this juncture more than a little distressing, especially when the British' and American Courts are doing their utmost to assist the authorities in making the roads safe. For them, in the execution of their very important duty, this newly emphasized limitation will prove extremely embarrassing unless it is speedily removed. That the matter cannot rest where it is must be obvious, and in the interest of the whole community we hope that the point will be tested in a higher comt directly occasion arises, and that, in the event of Mr. King's view being correct, speedy amendment of the T.and Regulations wil! follow.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account