Mes, 8. Wade was defendant to an action for $50,000 damages begun in ILM, Supreme Court on June 4 before Judge Sir Peter Grain and a special jury consisting of Messrs R. Phillips, RIN. Felgate, McKinney, 8, W. Wolfe, and Bryson, The action wax brought by Mr. WT, Andrews, who alleged that} aa the result of negligent driving on the part of the chauffeur of Mrs.
Wade's motor ear on June-24, 1929, it had come into collision with his at the junction of Route Herve de joyes and Avenue clu Roi Albert, causing permanent. physi injury'and monetary loss.
Counsel: Mx, Tycho Wing for the My, Ranald G, MeDonald Hartopp for the defendant, When the jury was being selected, Mx, Wing challenged the selection of Br. L, P. Quincey. Mr. Quincey was accordingly withdrawn, Mr. Donald also entered a formal ob-
Jection to the selection of Mr. R, N. Bryson on. the ground that he was employed by the same company as Mr, Andrews. Mr. Wing described this objection as "nothing but a yoying interrogatory" Mr. Bryson was not released from jury duty.
Mr. Wing said that Mr, Andrews: was 21 years and eleven months old and wax a shipping clerk in the employ of the BritishAmeriean 'Tobacro Ca. (China) Td, On June 24 she had been proceeding along Route Herve de Sieyes when, ut the crossing of that road with Avenue clu Ro} Albert, his cycle had been driven into by' Mrs, Wade's motor ear, which was being driven by a Chinese chauffeur. Mrs. Wade's chauffeur had been negligent, Mr. Wing said, in that he had not sound-his horn, had not kept a proper Took-out, had been driving at an excessive speed, and had not applied his brakes when Mr, Andrews came in. sight. acknowledged that at the time of the collision she had been talking £o her child in the ear and so had not witnessed it, Cross-examined by Mr, McDonald, Mr, Andrews said that his monthly salary at- the British<Ameriean Tobacco Ca., Ltd, was $170. He had been dri the same. motor cycle for about one year before the lent, He was ignorant of French tvaffie regulations and did not know] 4 that Regulation $9 thereof gave Mrs. Wade's car the right of way. Mrs. Wade's car had approached him at} excessive epeed and he had had no time to apply his brakes or otherwise avoid injury. He denied that he could have avoided the accident, that} he had been driving at a high speed, for that he had failed to sound his horn.
put it to you, Me. Andrews, Mr. MeDonald said, "that you were going at 20 miles per hour and the ear at 15 miles per hour; that you never applied your brakes at all that the ear did apply its brakes soon as the chauffeur saw you and thereafter went no more than 12 feet; that you could with the utmost] ease have avoided the accident by pulling up if you had chosen s0 to Nos that the ear sounded its horn, and that you never founded yours.
demonstration of the accident! was given by Mr, MeDonald by using models of a motor cycle and motor car, Photos of the scene of the accident were also submitted by hi er, Wings objected to the sion of these photos, and also to a suggestion by Mr. McDonald that} his Lordship and the jury should inspect the scene of the accident. 'The accident had occurred almost one year ago, Mr, Wing said, and the photos, which were taken quite recently, were not fair reproduetions of the condition of the roads' then. Many changes had been made 1 the accident, he said, including, the removal of a riding track, the, rounding off of some sharp corners, and the rection of buildings. Con-inspection be would My. Andvews had sustained fracture of the left collar-bone and fractures of both Tees und had suffered severe shock. He had had to undergo operations on June 28, 1,102, and July 19, We had since regained the we of his legs but in all probability would never regain their full use.
As the result of the collision, Mr. Wing said, Mr. Andrews had spent close upon five months in hospital and had disburyed Tis, 1,320.98 in 'A general denial of these allegations was entered by My. McDonald, fon behalf of Mrs. Wade. Mr, Me-Donald contended that if" any cident had happened to Mr. One drows as alleged he could and would by the exereite of ordinary care and discretion have avoided the same.
My. Andrews himself had been} negligent, My. McDonald said, in that he had not sounded his horn, Re-exam Mr. Andrews if he had made any attempt to interfere with the moter:
vole since the date of the accident it he had asked anyone to add its already extensive damages.
Mr. Wing: Has any agent of yours done anything to that motor: cycle for you, Mr. Andrews Inv. Andrews: Certainly not.
Mr. Wing: Have you tried to get it repaired?
My. Andrews: after I left! hospital Trent my brother to have look at it. He took a Chinese] fitter with him, but nothing was done to the motor cycle. T sent my brother as 1 could not' get around very well myself at the time. juryman asked if an obstructed view was obtainable in the vicinity of the accident when the collision occurred. Mr. Andrews had not kept " proper look-out, had. driven his motor cycle on the wrong: tide of the road, had driven his motor cycle at an excessive and improper speed, had failed to slow down or to stop in order to avoid accident, had failed to exercise due care and skill in the management his cycle, and ltd Waile's ear without giving any sufficient opportunity of avoid-said that a fence not in the photos submitted by Mr. MeDonald had obstructed the view at that time.
Concluding his examination Mr. Andrews, Mr. MeDonald asked. if he himself had paid the heavy medical fees or if-his employers had so. Mr. Andrews said that} is employers had paid them, but that he would have to repay them fall, Medical evidence was Wing then called Mr. D.
G. Gauntlett, who said that} 3 Price, director of the British-Mr, Andrews had veeeived the merican Ca. (China) Ltd, to Suriew mentioned and had been a testify as to the practice of the com Patient in St. Marie's Hospital and pany in allowing medical expenses the Country Hospital for the period to employees. Mr. Price said that} tated. is condition had been very employees of the British-American ous, £0 0 that at one time Tobacco Ca. were expected to pay fear was entertained for his life. their own medienl fees, "except in 'Phe operations on him had beensper= appropriate cases, when the formed after consultation with Dr. directors might decide to pay them." W. E. O'Mara, and the claim that Tt was "possible" that Mr. Andrews' he' would be permanently ineapaciat= expenses might be so allowed, was correct. For the rest of his although this was merely-a personal Vife he would be unable to par cipate in any of the athletic amani Mrs, Anastasia Semenoff, eye-wities known to young men. In answ ness of the collision between Bfr. to Mr. McDonald, Dr. Gauntlett said Andrews! cycle and Mrs. Wade's plainti? might be able to play golf.
Giving evidence on his own behalf, was next called by Mr. Wing. 'Mr. Andrews said that the motor She said she had seen' Mrs. Wade's cycle he was riding at the time of car proceeding at a high speed the collision was a 24 horsepower towards the spot where the accident Royal Enfield, whose maximum occurred. Its driver had not sound-speed was about 30 miles per have. ed the horn. She had not seen Mr. He had been driving at not Andrews until his cycle was run] than 15 miles per hour. The coll down by Mrs. Wade's car. She, the! Jad occurred as claimed and Mrs. driver of the ear, and a German Wade had visited him in hospital auth had put Mr. Andrews ina thereafter, at which time eke had car and sent him to hospital. No!
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.