Mr. Kentwell Doubts the Existence off Two Companies: Suggests Confusion During Translation: Judge on a Lawyer's Omissions: Denial of Receipt of Money In HIM, Supreme Court, last Pric day, before Judge Grain, Mr. L. K Kentwell continued his evidence defending the action brought against him by Chow Kwei-ching for any accounting in connexion with the winding-up of the Shanghai Chinese Coal Produce and Stock Exchange and the return of any money found due, Mr. Kentwell still was in the box when the further hearing was adjourned until Monday, and it was intimated that there wasa possibility of the ease being finished in une more sitting, on hearing which the Sudge romarked:—"T was beginning to wonder when we wee going t9 finish." Mr. M. B, Crown, with Mr, F, Sarda, appeared fee the plaintiff and Mr, Kentwell conducted his own ease.
Mz. Brown said he had seen a newspaper report which he wished to put right. A witness made an observation to the effect that at the Spi possible and he (Mr. Bro made to imply that he was beginning to agree with that. He wished make it clear that when he made that observation he referred only ta what took place in 1922 and he did not intend it in any way to apply to the present Spanish Consulate or ite_personnel, The Judge—I did not quite catch your remark at the time, but T Ehinke it best you should give such a statement to the Press. I thlux it is a very proper statement to make, No remarks in this case, am sure, in any way apply to the personnel of the present Consulate Mr, Kentwell drew the Judge's attention to an evening paps statement that he was rebuked by the Judge, The Judge—You must not_mind that." When I was at the Bar 1 sometimes received rebukes from the Tench, Tt is no good complaining because the Press notice it, Mr, Kentwell—But it was not correct.
'Mr. E. H, Baker, of Messrs, Seth, Mancell & MeLuve, recalled, said he Rad found amongst the' papers of the Shanghai Industrial Banking Corporation, a paying-slip showing that Gonzales paid in $8,877.50 in 1922, He also Grew a cheque for $22,000, made up of two items of $7,000 and $15,000.
Mr, Brown said it was. fairly obvious that only $26,000 passed through the trustee's "hands and $43,000 wore received. No more money could have passed through the trustee's hands.
The Judge, referring to the letter handed in by Mr. Kentwell on Thursday, said that the Spanish Consul very well might say he would not answer the questions as the inquiry regarding Gonzales was private and therefore he was privileged.
Continuing his evidence, Mr. Kentwell said that, in explanation of the discrepancy in registration, he! would refer to the correspondence with Fessenden & Holeomb, which he contended showed conclusively that it was the Spanish company' that was being wound up. stated:—"Chow Kwei-ching. states you are receiver for the Spanish company." As far as witness knew, the Shanghai Chinese company had'! a capital of $125,000, The Judge—ts it quite clear that} the Shanghai Chinese company was the one that was registered?
Mr. Kentwell—In a letter the Spanish Consul says "alia the Shanghai Chinese company.'
The Judge—I am not surprised. It is somewhat difficult to separate them even now. There are so many, names, Kentwell—The two boxes of papers I referred to have now been found and will be sent to the Court.
The Sudge—It is a little Into im the de:
Mr, "Kentwell produced another letter from the Spanish Consnt referring to the Shanghai Chinese company, 'The Judge—What keeps puzzling' me is that you are a lawyer and yet, when you saw an error, you. id-not correct it, Mr, Kentwell—These boxes will show that the originals were all Chinese and it was in the translation that the mistakes were made.
The Judge—Very obviously there were two companies, Mr. Kentwell—I don't think so.
Ihere could not possibly be. As regards the money, I only received the one amount 1' have mentioned and all the rest was received by Gonzales. This was known by Chow Kwel-ching. T wish to state now that it is @ deliberate falsehood on the part of Chow and his so say that T paid him on one occasion $9,000 and on another occasion $17,000. T have no knowledge of this money, which was received fron: Gonzales. Chow never consulted me about the Chinese company and there was no conversation with ins regarding the winding-up of the Spanish company in order to get money from the Chinese company.
Mr. Kentwell produced letters written by himself to the Spanish Consulate on behalf of the plaintiff. requesting payment of money stil due to the latter.
Referring again to documents supposed to be known to. the Spanish Consvlate, Mr. Kentwell said, that if those inspected by Mr. Covey were handed into Court, would clear up the whole case, they are afraid to produce them."
The Judge—Do you know what you are saying? You don't know What. the documents are and yet you say they would clear up the Whole ease, Mr. Kentwell—There is one particular. Thave a good idea what it The ease again was adjourned.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.