The Archive · 1926

Frequent Warnings Not to Be Insolent

Again on Tuesday there were frequent exciting passages between the defendant and Mr. M. B, Brown, representing the plaintiff, Mr. Brown repeatedly had to appeal to the Bench for protection, and Judge Grain, apart from reproving Mr: Kentwell for what he several times referred to as insolent and insulting behaviour, continually re minded him that, during cross examination, it was for a witness simply to answer questions and not to make speeches, and that there would be ample opportunity, when? later he conducted his own. re. examination and after that addressed. the Bench, to comment on any evidence given or questions put to him. There 'a more than usually large attendance of the general public and for Shanghai it was an exception to have the Judge find it necessary, when there was an outburst of laughter over one of Mr, Kentwell's remarks, to ree mind this present that there must be silence at the back of the Court.

The Missing Boxes Before going into the witness-box to be further cross-examined, Mr.

well said:—

"T have received a letter from the Spanish Consul which T have shown to Mr, Brown, who has no objection to it being put in. Tt shows that the Consul refuses one permission to inspect the register of company Only the Consul or an official appointed by the Spanish Government may do £0, I want to satisfy your Lordship that there {is nothing mysterious about the name.

The Judge—The Spanish Consol has answered that many times. You have three letters referring to the names, Mr. Brown—1 should like to inquire if an answer has been received from the Consul regarding the other letter.

The. Judge—No answer has been received.

Later in the case, @ message was brought to the Judge, who stated that it was a reply from Spanish Consul. The effect of the reply was that, as regards some of the questions put by Mr, Kentwell, the Consul considered it to be a privileged matter, the inquiry held at_ the Consulate having been private, so that he was not prepared to give answers, and to the mainder he gave only negative information, Mr. Brown-—I should further like to inquire if the boxes have been deposited in Court.

well?

The Judge—Have they, Mr. Kent.

Mr. Kentwell (heatedly)—I gave orders to the office to send them. Tam not a coolie to accompany the wheelbarrow coolie. T gave orders for them to be sent and I assume they are here. I gave orders and paid money for them and if they are not here it is not my fault, There things in Shanghai are not done personally.

The Judge—Very well, that is the answer, They Arrive After an inquiry had been made, the Judge said no boxes had arrived.

Mr. Kentwell—I am sure they must be. I paid 40 cents to have them sent over. I gave the money last night. It' is not for me to bring them.

Mr. Brown—I don't care who brings them so long as I get them, At this point the boxes arrived.

Mr, Brown—Have you been through the contents of these boxes?

Mr. Kentwell—I have not. T simply took two papers which I put in as exhibits.

Do you know what they contain?

don't know. They are all in inese. My interpreter told me they were share scripts.

Coxtinuing the eross-examination,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account