Public opinion here has been uncompromisingly opposed to the idea of foreign-controlled railway police from the very beginning. Foreign public opinion has been opposed, because the scheme involved superficial intervention which would irritate all classes of Chinese and! challenge the officials to connive with the bandits to discredit it: because it did not promise to hold the Chinese military officials to their fundamental obligations to either foreigners or Chinese, but relieve ed them of responsibility for the maintenance of order along the lines; and because all reliable foreign observers of conditions in China were suto that under present. conditions no system of railway police, short of armies of occupation which the railways could not support, would be adequate to protect the line against resourceful raiders unless the territories through which the railways passed were properly policed and controlled by the local military. Chinese opinion has been opposed to the scheme for the reason that it entailed a degree of intervention, sufficient to establish a precedent of intervention, but insufficient to guarantee China any material benefits.
Criticism of the plan for putting the rai¥way poligp of the northern lines under General Munthe's command, would be very much freer and more outspoken here if it were not fox the universal respect which General Munthe's ability as an officer and integrity as a man command. There would also be more outspoken comment if it were not understood that, under a comprehensive reform programme in China, lines of communication in China—railways and waterways—would be given first. consideration, and that no plan which has the least chance of protecting communications should not be lightly rejected.
These are strong incentives to silence, but not strong enough to suppress a very general expression of the conviction that the whole scheme, whether brought forward by domestic initiative or under foreign pressure, is going to prove utterly futile unless the big militia chiefs can be coaxed or forced into the use of their troops for the maintenance of order within the districts over which their titles give them real or nominal jurisdiction.
From the moment that tile Lincheng outrage was first reported every Occidental of any experience living in China felt that th: one sure way to guarantee the railway. against further molestation was to force Tsao Kun, who decorates himself with the title of Inspector-General of Chihli, Honan and Shantung, to admit that he was personally responsible for the disturbed conditions which made the Lincheng affair possible and to force him to resign his office and submit his person to the recognized Government for punishment. This still remains the only possible fundamental preventive of such incidents as the Lincheng incident; and because the punishment of Tsao Kun is the only possible guarantee of immunity from such incidents, whether on railways or highways or byways, every other suggested meastire must appeal to foreign residents in China as an evasion, if the initiative comes from the Chinese, or as the outgrowth of either ignorance or cowardice if the initiative come from the foreigner.
According to Occidental tradition, all persons, irrespective of caste or station, are equal before the law. According to the same tradition all,' foreign residents dwelling in "China under extra territorial jurisdiction are entitled to equal protection. The poor Japanese pedlar who follows a trail in the mountains of Shantung is entitled to just as much solicitous consideration, from his Legation and, by inference, from the hinese authorities, as the wealthy concessionaire who charters a compartment on a Blue Express or any other train. The man who, within' his treaty rights, navigates canal in Hunan in a native junk should be just' as important in the sight of his Legation as the man who captains a steamer on the Yangtze. For the Legations to discriminate and say: "We can protect this dre butsnot that one," is to confess to the Chinese that we have abandoned the defence of principles and are content to confine ourselves to the defence of "'interests." Such discrimination is an invitation to the Chinese to discriminate also, an invitation to them to ignore treaties and play up to interests—a programme within which Chinese official ingenuity will always outwit and defeat the best laid foreign schemes.
For the same good reasons, when an incident like the Lincheng affair, arouses a storm of foreign feeling in the Orient, which rumbles even into the Occident and moves our Home Governments to thought, any effort on the part of restricted vested interests, such as the railway interests, to monopolize attention and focus governmental patronage upon its own particular claims, thereby diverting attention from fundamental problems and making it possible for the
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.