The Archive · 1923

PROFESSOR GILES

Te the Editor of the "Norra-Catna Darty News."

Sir,—What was your object in publishing a vile, spiteful and libellous attack on my father in in your correspondence columns? Who is "J. A. J." that he finds it obligatory on. "him to take up the cudgels on behalf of the. late Mr. Mayers (not Mayer) whose two sons, both well-known in China, are well able to Jock after their father's interests? What grounds had your 1898 reviewer for asserting that a large amount of material collected by Mr. Mayers had placed at my father's disposal, but that the latter had forgotten to motion it? What grounds has "J, A. J." for alleging that the bulk of the material in my father's Biographical Dictionary came from Mr: Mayers? If any material collected by Mr. Mayers was as a matter of fact offered to my father, it was most certainly not used by him—doubtless because it was not suitable for his purpose. To anyone acquainted with my father's scrupulous sense of honour the suggestion that he "forgot"? to acknowledge an indebtedness or chose to.strut about in borrowed plumes is simply contemptible. I think that the very least you yourself can do is to apologize for having associated yourself with a scurrilous traducer, a malignant muck-raker.

I am, ete., Changsha, July 25, 1923.

"", Ihe letter complained of was published solely because it appeared to refer to a point of interest to controversialists in Chinese bibliography, and as such we presumed it would be read. The personal feature of the case was unfortunately overlooked, and of course, we regret that it should have occasioned so much pain to Mr. Giles.—Ed.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account