The Archive · 1923

DR. FRANK CRANE AND' PROHIBITION

To the Editor of the "Norrs-Cama Dairy News."

Sir,—Dr. Frank Crane's letter to a man in Shanghai which appears in your issue of to-day has been read by me with great interest. At any rate we may feel assured that Dr. Crane only says what he thinks. but there are others. May I be allowed to put before your public, in, I hope, as prominent position as Dr. Crane's "Letter to a man in Shanghai" the opinion of Dr. Nicholas Murray Butler, President of Columbia University, and one of the most famous of America's educationalists, as stated in a recent home publication. (Harper's Wine Spirit Gazette).

The Volstead Act, Dr. Butler declares, is a, lie, and a lie which flatly contradicts the Eighteenth Amendment itself. Any political party which proposes to keep it on the Statute Book, unrevised and unamended, will find itself defeated at the polls—in many States overwhelmingly. The Prohibition question has been kept out of national party pro-rammes for a generation through lear of political consequences, but it cannot be kept out of the minds of the voters any longer. The people are shocked and alarmed at the nation wide hypocrisy and lawlessness which have followed the adoption of the Eighteenth Amendment, and at the nation wide traffic illicit, uncontrolled and untaxed, in alcoholic liquors. Dr. Butler makes some caustic comments about: Pussyfoot lecturers lauding the "benefits of prohibition" and commends them to a study of conditions," say in Georgia and in Colorado, both of which States were supposed to be dry before there was any Federal legislation whatsoever."

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account