The Archive · 1923

A Letter to a Man in Shanghai

Dr. Frank Crane, the well-known American journalist who has been spend: ing several days as a visitor to Shanghai, has contributed the following. response to a query by a -local resident.

A man from Shanghai writes me, in substance, that, noting 2 have recently visited his city,~ and believing that I am in a position to know American conditions pretty well, that I am not a fanatic nor a propagandist, and that I am honest enough to tell the truth as I see.it, he would like to get from me my views on Prohibition in the United States.

From the newspapers he gets the most diverse, opinions. 1s Prohibition a farce? Is it being violated everywhere? Will it be repealed? Or modified?

My answer is simple. Prohibition is in the United States to stay. The saloon is gone forever. The law may possibly be modified, but not probably in our lifetime but the gist of it will remain.

Alcoholic beverages will never again be sold openly on the street all comers.

This drug has been placed for all time along with opium, cocaine and other habit forming drugs, to be sold only under the supervision of the medical profession.

Prohibition rests upon a Constitutional Amendment. Thid is the hardest kind of Jaw in the world to pass.

First, an amendment must receive an overwhelming majority in both the National Senate and House. After that it must be ratified by three-fourths of the State Legislatures. All this takes much time, and the utmost pubplicity.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account