The Archive · 1923

Fire Insurance Law

Interesting Decision by Judge Lobingier on a Question of Mis-description of Locality Judge Lobingier has given an interesting decision in a fire insurance case where the defence of mis-description of locality had been raised. e case, which was tried in the United States Court for China, was at the instance of Ping Kee against the Fireman's Fund Insurance Ca. Messrs, Haskell & Moss were for the plaintiff and Messrs. Davies and Bryan for the defendants. His Honour's decision is as follows This is an action on two fire insurance policies issued by defendant to plaintiff covering goods stored in a building known as Kung Zai Godown, situated on the corner of North Thibet Road and North Soochow Road in the city of Shanghai. The building had two compartments, one opening on the first named road and known as No. 1 North Thibet Road, and the other opening on North Soochow Road, known as No. 64 of that road. The goods insured by both policies were located in the last named compartment, but the insured, who was a Chinese and neither speaks nor reads English, testified that he knew the place only as Kung Zai Godown and in fact had never visited the interior, There was no written application for either policy and the testimony is undisputed that the insured in each instance merely informed the insurer's compradore by telephone that he desired insurance on goods located in the Kung Zai Godown.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account