The Archive · 1923

The Denial of Liability

A fire having occurred which~ destroyed the goods, and proof of loss having been furnished, defendant denied liability because of the phrase "No. 1 North Thibet Road' instead of "No. 64 North Soochow Road," invoking the clause exempting. it from liability" "if there be any material misdescription of any building or Place in which such property is contained." The first' question presented then is whether the use, in connexion with the name of the godown, of the street number other than that of the compartment in which the goods were stored constitutes a "material misdescription." The general Tule on this point is thus stated in a leading work:—3 _"If the property is otherwise uficiently identified, or, casting out what la false in the description, there is still enough left to clearly point out the place where the property is, a misdescription as to location will not avoid tha policy." a case on all fours with this, the insured property was described as _con' in "Overland free warehouse No. 1, situated at the northeast. corner of i and Keys Streets, San Francisco." In fact it was located in warehouse

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account