The Archive · 1923

NO MATERIAL MISDESCRIPTION

It seems clear from the foregoing decisions that the use of the phrase "No. 1 North Thibet Road'' in connexion -with the proper description of the godown and the cadastral lot did not constitute a "material misdescription"' as that phrase is applied and construed by the Courts. But had it been otherwise we doubt if such misdescription would, under the circumstances of this case, effect a forfeiture of the insurance, for, as we have seen, misdescription, if any, was not that of the insured at all, but of the insurer's agent or employee. It is elementary that a party cannot take advantage of his own wrong or mistake, or that of any representa. tive, and the rule applies with special force to insurance companies, dealing as they are with those unfamiliar with their methods and, as in this case, with one unacquainted with the language in which the policy was written.

Finally it must be remembered that there was no written application which alone distinguishes: many of the cases relied upon by defendant and, moreover, constitutes a waiver of errors and omissions known to the insurer.

As the claim of "material misdescription" constitutes the sole defence (for the averment of total loss is not denied) we must find-that plaintiff is entitled to recover on both policies and it is accordingly considered and adjudged that he have and recover from the defendant the sum of Tls. 6,500 with interest thereon from the date of furnishing proofs of loss (which are admitted in the answer) together with his costs.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account