The Archive · 1923

"LADIES COMPANION" CASE

Failure of Plaintiff's Claim for Salary in Action in the United States Court Judgment has been delivered b; Judge Lobingier in the Unite States Court for China inthe action at the instance of Harold Russell against the L. C. Publishing Ca.

In this case Messrs. Haskel] Moss appeared for the plaintiff and Messrs. Schuh] & Schoenfeld for the defendants.

His Honour's decision is as follow This is an action to recover an amount alleged to be due plaintiff as vice-president and general manager of defendant company "at a stipulated salary of Tls. 600 per month."' The amended answer of said Plaintiff was Tls. 600, but in "Denies that the stipulated salary

this respect defendant alleges that it was agreed by and between the plaintiff and defendant corporation at the plaintiff was only to receive Tle. 600 per month, provided the said defendant made sufficient profit to pay the same.'?

A counterclaim for Tls. 1,250, for money alleged to have been received from defendant by plaintiff is also pleaded.

Plaintiff relies upon a resolution embodied in the minutes of a meeting of the directors of the @efendant company on October 4, 1922, consisting of plaintiff and two others, reading as follows:

"Resolved that the vice-president be, and hereby is appointed the general manager of the company at a salary of Tis, 600 per month and that the same salary shall be.paid to the President.""

The minutes of the same body at a meeting on April 3, 1923, with the same directors present, recites that plaintiff "Admitted that it was the understanding of the officers, directors and stockholders of the company, that the salary of Tls. 600 per month to be paid to the President and General Manager, were only to be paid if and when the profits of the company permitted such payment."?

MINUTES OF DIRECTORS' MEETING, Two. of the directors testified to the effect that the recital in the second resolution correctly set forth the proceedings at the first meeting, and one of them, the corporate secretary, testified that the minutes containing the first resolution were prepared in advance and that one of the directors raised the objection that the resolution itself did not embody the provisions authorizing payment only when the profits of the company justified it. oes Plaintiff in his evidence on the subject does not unequivocally contradict the testimony of the' other directors, nor wun-equivocally state the salary was other fixed date. His conte, to begin immediately or at any'

called: after the two other witnesses had testified, would not_ deny that plaintiff had admitted at the second meeting the recitals

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account