The Archive · 1920

The West End Jade Robbery

Case Against Trevor Dismissed Ernest_ Charles Trevor, alias Ernest Norman, 29, appeared on remand before Mr. G. W_ King at 'H. M. Police Court last Friday, on the following charge: "for that he did on August 30, 1920, at Shanghai, wound and cause grievous bodily harm to Wong Sing-fong, with intent to murder him; further, that he on the same date did steal eight jade stone necklaces approximately valued at $5,000, the property of the said Wong Sing-fong."

Accused was further charged for that on various dates between August 7 and September 10, in the International Settlement. he did sell fire-arms without first having obtained a license from the Municipal Council. contrary to by-law Mr. R. C. Faithfull appeared for the prosecution, and Mr, P. W. Goldring represented the accused.

Mr. Faithfull informed his Worship that the Police had been unable to obtain evidence of identification and in the circumstances there was not sufficient evidence to justify their going on with the charge. The Police had no doubt whatever but that they had got the right man.

His Worship:—Oh, come, Mr. Faithfull, you must not say things like that if you are not prepared to Mr. Paithfull:—On the information obtained the Police were perfectly justified in bringing this charge.

His Worship:—That is a different thing. They were perfectly right if they had a reasonable suspicion.

Mr. Faithfull:—Not only reasonable, but a very strong case. But in the circumstances, I must ask your worship to allow the police to withdraw the charges.

His Worship:—You want the charges of larceny and attempted murder withdrawn Counsel:—Yes sir.

His Worship:—You really want to withdraw these two charges?

Counsel:—Yes sir.

His Worship:—Very Tre. well, vor, you are discharged.

Mr, Faithfull:—I am_ instructed to prefer a further charge against this man, that of selling fire-arms without a license.

His Worship:—It does seem rather a drop, from attenipted murder to an offence under a by-jaw.

Mr. Goldring:—On that point I can do nothing but plead guilty. My client admits having sold the firearms. I do not know whether the Court would like to go into the circumstances or not.

His Worship:—It seems such an extraordinary procedure. I was reading quite recently a case in the Appeal Court, in which strong comment was made upon the addition of a charge of robbery to an indictnient for murder. It was

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account