The Archive · 1926

Widows' Fund & Life Assurance

Society—one of the best known insurance companies in the! world—sought to obtain powers "to undertake and execute trusts of all kinds, and to undertake the offices of trustee, executor, administrator, agent, factor, liquidator, treasurer or auditor." Exception' was taken by the Institute of Chartered Accountants) in England and Wales to the powers of acting as trustee, liquidator, receiver and auditor, fand the case was argued before Select Committee of the House of Lords. The decision of the Select Committee was to uphold the objection of the Institute of Chartered Accounts, and in the matter of acting trustee, the amendment was introduced' giving the company power "to undertake and execute trusts of all kinds and to undertake the offices of trustee (other than trustee in bankruptcy or a trustee under a deed of arrangement with creditors)." It is] this refusal of the House of Lords to permit a limited liability company as such to perform duties ordi ily carried jour by individuals which provides} the great interest in this case, and which makes it well worth examining.

Certain specific reasons operated to make the Scottish) Widows' Fund desirous of acquiring the powers which were refused. Counsel for the insurance company put the matter' quite clearly in the following terms:—

There is\no objection here taken to the Scottish Widows' Fund acting! fas a trustee. But, of course, it has very considerable implications, because once your act as a trustee you! have very considerable duties, and may, as a trustee, have an interes for example in a bankruptey. Sup: Posing a trust had a claim against a bankrupt's estate, it may be the largest creditor of that estate, and very proper that the bank or!

surance company which isthe trustee of that estate should obtain the administration in bankruptey of that particular estate. Or again, it may have a very large and predommating holding in a company] which is going into liquidation, and in it is very desirable that the gest creditor should have an opportunity of taking part in the liquidation of the company and of being appointed liquidator if seen fit.

Now, in practice, when a bankruptcy or liquidation takes place, it is generally found that the accountant to carry it out is nominated by the largest credi-for or by the company or individual having the largest interest in the matter, and thi nomination is generally _approved. The smaller creditors in such cases have seldom reason to question the motives or integrity of the party making such 'a nomination, but it is always open to them, should they consider their interests as liable to be prejudiced, to withhold their consent. As we have just said, however, this happens only on very rare occasions, and in the circumstances it might surely be suggested that if given such' powers, a very large organization such. as the Scottish Widows' Fund would be in a position to carry through liquidations and bankruptey matters more economically than when recourse must be had to Chartered Accountants or other outside experts in this line of business. However much might be said on this aspect of the case, the ruling] of the Select Committee of the House of Lords refused to allow] the corporation to undertake such' duties.

There was no suggestion that the Scottish Widows ever dream: ed of competing with Chartered, Accountants in the ordinary] course of their business: the provisions were asked solely that} they might be used when the ig] company's interests were at stake. What, however, defeated such considerations as these is that the law of the land to-day] demands personal responsibility. It was pointed out although Sir William Plender is often ap-Pointed to the position liquidator by a court, the firm of which he is a partner, De-lotte, Griffiths & Ca., never is. It is always an individual partner, and he is personally responsible. The whole idea, said counsel, and the whole conception of' a receiver is bound up with the personal individuality of the individual appointed, Again to quote counsel for the Institute of Chartered Accountants:

Supposing a Court were to appoint] the insurance company a receiver, the Court could not bring before it the local manager or clerk who had been exercising the duties... and finding that he had been acting] improperly commit him to prison, That could not be done, and all the sense of personal responsibility. would be entirely absent from the person who exercises the real duties. It is very important that such a view should have been upheld. H¥t is not the case of the Scottish Widows' Fund with which we are concerned now, but the fact that, our law will still insist on a definite personal liability and tone which cannot be merged in soulless incorporated company Jwhich at best could only be held responsible in monetary damages. We have seen a good deal in Shanghai of how the act of incorporation is made to cover up or remit personal _responsibility, the recent opinion of the British' Mixed Court Assessor dealing exhaustively with that point, and it would certainly not be for the good of professional] and commercial work if this were to become a general rule, That an insurance company with the great assets of the Scottish Widows should do trustee work in the ordinary way carried out} by insurance companies is all to the good, giving as it does an absolute security to the trust} which no individual can offers} but there is the other aspect as revealed in this case where we are better protected by individual than by corporate responsibility.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account