To the Editor of the "Nontu-Cuina Datty News"
Sin,—Mr. Rodney Gilbert's article, "Chinese Speeulate in published in your August 11 issue, is certainly a clever if not valid analysis, Briefly, it may be thus st med up: The Chinese are buying rail-[way bonds "hungrily," because they believe in the inevitability of foreign {intervention in China when "the bonds will go up at once to par value and those who bought them when they were low, careless {interest and careless of their intrinsic worth, will make huge profits Obviotsly, Mr. Gilbert has over-{ookeg certain fundamental economic principles governing any apecula: ive market, be it bonds, money exchange, or produce exchange. Firstly, any bond, no matter how well secured it may' be, cannot be absolutely free from a speculative nature, because {ts value is dependent on factors over which it has no control, and secondly, the less adequately secured a bond fs, the more active fy the market for ft, because it fs capable of wider fluctuations and therefore wider gins for speculation. This in evidenced, on the one hand, by the Inaetive market for Chinese domestic Even if we go back to the days when the British income tax ace tually amounted to 1/. in the we find that for the year 1904-05 Ite revenue amounted to £81,260,- 600 and for the year 1908-09 39,700,000, Allowing for changes "a6 system of taxation, diferent sumptions, and the exclusion of Irish Free State from present figures it would nog seem that vere is any real ground for the egestion that our London corres-pendent has indulged in any exaggeration at all, but that "E.C.W." fee evolved an absurdity out of his avisapprehension of whey as write for 4 wad ft, the ibe, concerning the straw and the camel's back, 'E.C.W." will peruse the Shaan! Wp ok Rts "st he Grant al vain ca ead Nation, canto. Per Nati
percent. Great pass France io Rontvinaiangsy 20. 8 Germany ers: R988
The wer gqite an expensive. proposition "to Great Britain who. ig left thick' end of th stick to hold, does not complain overmuch Donds that are well secured and, on the other, by the active and erratic market for the so-called "6" Million Salt Surplus Bonds which are inadequately secured.
Like other bonis, railway bonds} fare governed by the same economic! principles. If the Chinese speculator has bought railway bonds in antiipation of foreign intervention with immediate improvement of railways and recovery of trade conditions in! China, then he will meet with certain disappointment. The fall cabinet or any serious pol turbance in any country has almost always exerted a depressing influence on the market for bonds or currency of that country. This well ilhistrateg by the decline of the frane during the last few months. Foreign intervention in China, such Br. Gilbert s0 ardently wishes, will certainly be of more grave significance than the fall of any cabinet or political disturbance in any country, and consequently influence will be infinitely more detrimental to the Chinese bond market. In other words, when tervention comes, I can predict an immediate fall inthe value of all Chinese bonds including railway bonds, because the very authority on which they depend for their market value is overthrown. If Mr. Gilbert requires an actual illustration of what foreign intervention will do to the speculative market, he need not further than the Allied Occupation of the Ruhr in Germany and the food it has done to the German If the Chinese speculators have been buying railway bonds heavily, is @ proof in itself of their ce fidence in the ultimate salvation of "ome, De News China through her own efforts, because foreign intervention, as plained before, will depreciate at not appreciate the value of bonds and ig therefore undesirable from the Kingdom," I beg to quote for the standpoint of the speculater. More: over, as far I know, the market in Shanghai is railway bonds. action is done, it favourable rate of exchange for Sterling in which all Chinese railway bonds are quoted.
If, Mr. Gilbert's article referred! "-gwn use and not for sale will not] to Peking alone whence he wrote, be required to pay duty. This! then he must have been ill-informed. concession was made yesterday Some time ago a certain important the House of Commons on a motion financier made a public _statement by: BMx.: R, MeNeiil. He said the that. all Chinese. railway bonds proposal "would cos "35,000" 8 were not, secured. as to. their 3
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.