Brothers & Ca., Inc.
On a demurrer in this action, involving an interesting question of partnership, His Honour de livered the following judgement This is an action for the alleged breach of a contract for the sale by defendant to plaintiff of certain cotton spinning machinery. Defendant by way of "set off" alleges the breach by plaintiff of a contract for the sale of other similar machinery to the defendant by plaintiff and "One K. Karahari, a Japanese citizen." Plaintiff now demurs to that portion of the petition—containing the "'set off" for lack of mutuality in the two claims.
The practice of "setting off" the respective claims of advereo parties to litigation originated in the civil Jaw where it was known as compensation. There was nothing corresponding to it in the common law, and wherever the practice prevails in common law countries it derives from legislation. In this jurisdiction it rests upon a rule of court promulgated in 1861, and providing as follows:
"In actions of contract, defendant offset petitioner's claim counter-claim, filing his own under oath,' with hig answer. Peti tioner shall be notified to file his answer seasonably, on oath, and the two claims shall then be tried together, and but one judgement given for the difference, if any be proved in favour of either' party, otherwise for defen Plaintiff's counsel rely on a line of authorities to the effect that "In a suit by a partner a firm debt due defendant can not be pleaded as a set off."
Some of these decisions rest on the legal fiction of the partnership entity differing from the individual partners. while other are based on statutes which expressly require that the claims to be set off must be mutual. As we have seen, there is no such requirement in the court regulation above quoted which prevails here even over the acts of Congress.
But whatever may be the rule, in the absence of statute. as regards partnerships. it would not necessaily govern this case because it is nowhere_alleged that the contract which defendant relies upon by wa: of set off is that of a partnership. In the copy, attached to, the answer, the contractees are Teferred to merely as "the buyers." and while Clause_13 of the contract provides that "Each individual partner of the Buyers' Hong shall be respon-
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.