The Archive · 1930

FOREIGN ¥. M, C. A

To the Editor of the "Noxrn-Cuina Dairy News."

Sir,—I am sorry that the numer-fous commentators on my letter re the cost of living at the Foreign Y.M.C.A., did not do me the honour of reading it, else they would have spared themselves the energy of proving that my monthly account comes to more than $120. I compared the cost of room and chow for $130 outside with the cost covering the same items at the Y. namely, Room, $50, Chow $65. Cumsha $5, figures that can be easily ye fied, and that are in no way. misleading. My Association membership is paid whether I live at the or not,.and is not a legitimate charge to room rent or chow, except to contra both accounts, which could be done with subscriptions to a dozen or so other clubs to which 1 belong, and which brings' us nowhere, Your correspondents who. abouts, have not the grace to plain that this figure includes such itenis as barbering, billiards, taxis, valet service and £0 on. "My original letter makes it abundantly clear that I was concerned only with cost of room and beard.

Thad really hoped that 1 should get comparative costs from foreignfers who are living in private rooms, firms messes where similar con jences could te obtained, but with the exception of the poor Beggar who wonders how he could manage with $80 a month pocket money, and whose fatuous observations on the size of the rooms amply demonstrate that he had never seen tone, all the letters are from re dents of the In order then, 1 will reply, first to the Christian stomachs," and advise that they do not try so religiously to get their money's worth from the fourteen courses on the menu, Even Christian stomachs can have too much of a good thing. The shade of Gilbert will overlook the insult. on the ground that stomachs have no brains.

Why should K assume that a $50 room (not the cheapest), is une comfortable. There is exactly the same appointments and service as the most expensive room in the building. I use my room to sleep, perform the necessary ablution: ress and store my clothes and pro: perty in, With a well-appointed ourige and library, there is no mason for me to spend any more me in my room than is required for these purposes, and for which I assure K the room is most amply convenient and comfortable, As for ex Route Doumer, I ean-not help but admire his literary gifts more than his erudition, I not, Sir, pay $60 for my room, and certainly not $6 for morning tea and $7.50 for afternoon tea, "He these items are necessary to well beings not the only thing in his letter that leads me to imassize he must be dotage, ard ought to be in a nursing home in: stead of the Foreign Y.M.CA, for the swimming pool, the ¥ pool is the only one in the City where a modern sterilization, filtration, and suction cleaning plant is used daily, and a hot shower with soap is me fisted upon before entering the pool. A swimming pool is one of the most potent spreaders of disease, and for the above reasons I still maintain that the ¥ pool is the best, I am sorry that the correspondents, who live at the Y cannot ving themselves to more than grudgingly admit that the place is convenient and the prices reasonable. Ido not in the least apologize for feeling happy about the only place in Shanghai that for me at east makes life cut here tolerable, and Iam humbly thankful for the many friends I have made there, and the happy hourt 1 have spent in their company ait the Foreign Shanghai, July 7, 2920,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account