The Archive · 1926

Defence Analysed

There are certain statements which the defendant has constantly made during the hearing of this lease that I purpose to deal with at once. any and that the defendant would then pay the plaintiff back his $34,- 600 and $5,000 and the proper proportion of the balance as a shareholder in the first company.

The Money Received In March, 1922, the defendant was appointed liquidator of the Spanish company and advertised as such, stating that all claims were to be sent in to him. On April 3, 1922, the defendant, signing himself Counsel for Official Trustee, obtained an order from the Mixed. Court against 18 banks to pay to the "Oficial Receiver" a sum in total $45,378 deposited in the various banks, in the name of the Shangh: Ctinete Coal Produce & Stock Bxchange Company. The amount paid into the Mixed Court on this Order of Court was $8,877.50 which was rent by the Court to the defendant 'This amount was made up of $2,800 paid in by the Industrial Development Bank and $6,077.50 'Ming Shing Bank (Modern Citi gens' Bank). The remainder, $36,501, swas paid by the other banks and appears to have passed through the banking accounts of one Gonzales, who is described as Official Trustee of the winding-up of the companies. The plaintiff had adveneed $34,000 and $5,900 to the first company, paid the defendant as his lawyer fees $5,500 and retaining fee $400, dpa also, had to pay a. judgment elvan against him for $854.80 and costs to newspapers for advertise-

(a) That it-was Gonzales, the Official Trustee, who received all the money. (b) That many things were done by his interpreter without his, knowledge.

That he was compelled to carry on the liquidation by the Spanish Consulate under the orders of the Official Trustee and without any powers as liquidator, and that all duties" were superseded by the appoint mont of the Official Trustee almost directly after his own' appointment as liquidator, And further, that these events took place so long ago that he has forgotten many things that happened and many details.

With regard to (a), if his statement is correct, why did not the defendant have' the evidence of Gonzales taken on commission before Gonzales left Shanghai? Gonzales iwas in Shanghai trading and had jcfices as a merchant in 1924 and 1925 and did not leave till the end pi Jof January this year. The writ {was issued against defendant on December, 1924, and Statement of Claim filed January 17, 1925, There }was ample time to obtain the evi-Jdence of Gonzales on commission Jand the defendant would have had no, difficulty in obtaining it, be: Jcause in this ease the present Spanish Consul-General has shown every

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account