The Archive · 1926

A Curious Legal Tangle

Many Claimants to a U.'S. Consular Lot: An Absconding Compradore's Liabilities Another step has been taken towards the solution of a highly complicated legal problem that has been exercising the French and Internaional Mixed Courts and the U. 8, Court for China, with French, German, American and Chinese citizens involved, but even now it appears to be a long way from a final settlement. The Behn Meyer China Ca., Ld,, successors to Hugo Stinnes, were the holders of a title deed to U.S. lot 3087, registered with the U. 8, Consulate-General in the name of Mr, Leonard W. Hartigam This title deed was handed to the firm as security by its former compradore, Ho Hong-ping, who has absconded and is alleged to owe the firm $50,000, The value of the property covered by the title deed fs about Tis, 70,000, In May, 1925, the French firm of Racine & Cie. obtained judgment against Ho Hong-ping for Tls. 68,000 and made an attachment on the title deed by' order of the French Mixed Court, which ordered Messrs, Behn Meyer not to part with it for any reason whatsoever, At the same time, Racines filed an action in the French)

Mixed Court to have the property sold, the proceeds to be distributed among the preferred and ordinary creditors of Ho Hong-ping.

The French Mixed Court, after lengthy arguments before the Assesser (Mr. Tulasne) and the Magistrate (Mr. Zeng Kia-tehing) now has delivered judgment in th action, The plaintiffs, represen by Mr, P, Premet (of Mr. A. clu pac de Marsoulies's law offices) brought action against Ho Hong-ping and the Behn Meyer China Ca., Ld. the latter being represented by Mr, Brault, The Behn Meyer China Ca. did not raise any objection, provided their claim on the compradore was paid. There was a surprise when Cha Wan-tsang intervened, acting through his counsel, Mr. Richer, and opposed the sale, claiming that he was the owner of the property. He said he handed Ho Hong-ping title deed as security against a loan and that Ho Hong-ping fraudulently disposed of the deed, by giving it as security to Hugo Stinnes. TH claimed accordingly that the title deed he returned to him against payment of Tls. 30,000, the amount of the loan received from Ho Hong-which he offered to repay at] any time.

The Court in its judgment rejected the claim of Cha Wan-tsang and ruled that the claim of Racine Ca. was well established. The Ca held that Cha Wan-tsang was unable to prove his rights of property in the land and that, even if satisfactory evidence could be brought, the property covered by the title deed belonged, as far as the creditors! were concerned, to the assets of Ho Hong-ping and had to be considered accordingly. It had been finally and uncer Accordingly, all the creditors of lo. Hong-ping had the right to consider the land in litigation as the property of Ho Hong-ping and were authorized to make good their rights, The Court accordingly ordered the sale of the land within three months.

In the meantime, another action was filed before the U. S. Court for China, by Cha Wan-tsang against the registered owner, Mr, Leonard W. Hartigan, for return of the deed against payment of Tls. 30,000 borrowed from Ho Hong-ping. Cha Wan-tsang (represented by Mr. Schuhl), Br. Hartigan (represented by Dr."H, C. Mei) and the Behn Meyer China Ca,, Ld. (by Mr. W. Y. Char) reached an agreement that Judgment be entered in favour of the Behn Meyer China Ca., Ld., in the sum of Tls. 26,615, to be deposited by Cha Wan-tsang in the International Bank and that Mr. Hartitransfer his legal title in the property to Cha Wan-tsang, and that, upon the communication of such transfer, the Behn Meyer China Ca, Ld, may withdraw the money from the bank.

Judge Purdy then raised the question whether the U. S. Court could order the delivery of a title deed to a party when the property was in litigation between two] parties, neither of whom was of! willing to render judgment against Mr. Hartigan he said, bat he could not order anything to be handed to a citizen of another country while it was in dispute.

Eventually, it was decided that Behn Meyer would apply to the International Mixed Court and get judgment against Ho Hong-ping and hen have it carried out by the U.

Court for China,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account