The Government faced another crisis today whos its Coal Mines Bill was returned to the House of Lords for the third time for reconsideration of" the compromise Commons. modifications made in the House of
The House of Lords was crowded for the debate.
Special interest centred in the so-called "spread over" "amendment Which had been introduced by the Lords and which was objected to by the Commons. This amendment permitted a 90-hour fortnight instead of a Ti-hour day as originally proposed in the Bi Lord Salisbury, the leader of the (Conservative opposition in the House of Lords, foreshadowed the acceptance of the minor "Commons! amendments, but, firmly adhered to the "spread over" proposal.
The Lord Chancell the Government was unable to accept the "spread over"' amendment and the members of the House of Commons, he declared, were to-a man opposed to it.
This was generally taken to mean the Bill was doomed if the Lords insisted upon voting for the "spread over" amendment, When a division was taken the Lords by 168 votes to 36 insisted upon the amendment and the Coal Mines Bill is now regarded as dead.
The Bill, as originally drafted, dealt with three specific subjects, marketing schemes, the reduction of the working day below ground to '74 hours with one winding time and the setting up of a National Wages Board. The first pert proposed to regulate the production, supply and sale of coal by means of a central ce-ordinating scheme for the whole lof Great Britain and district schemes [oer all colliery di 'The principal Liberal amendment to the Bill in the House of Commons was as follows:—"This House, while favouring a reduction of miners' hours and the establishment of a Coal Mines National Industrial Board, cannot approve a Bill which does' nothing to promote the reorganization of the industry and secure a reduction of costs of production through higher efficiency; but which, on the contrary, would give a statutory vested interest to inefficient pits and would subsidze the coal supplied to com peting manufacturers abroad, while increasing the price of coal to British industries and imposing a heavy burden on consumers in general."
During the course of the debates Mr. Lloyd George characterised the Bill as "incredibly bad"
"It contains, in my judgment," he said," the features. of worst the redeeming—featui is State interference without State protection. It has all the greed of individualism without of the stimulus of competition, for that reason, it is exceedingly dificult for anyone, whether he be individualist or Socialist, to find a tingle creditable argument in favour of it"
July 16.
Following a meeting with the miners the Government has suggested to the House of Lords that there should be a conference 1#- garding the "spread-over" amen'- ment to the Coal Mines Bill. The [Gorernment expresses the opinion that the re-organization features in the Bill ought not to be sacrificed if the Lords' standpoint can reasor~ uly Fe met.
"The Coal Mines Bill redueed the yorking day below ground to 7 jours. The "spread-over" "amend. ment upon which the House of Fords insists permits a 90-hour Zertnight instead of a 74-hour day.
was generally thought when. the House of Lords voted for the "bread-over" amendment, which the Commons refuse to accept, that Reuter. the Coal Mines Bil was dead,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.