The Archive · 1926

Security of Domestic Bonds

Now why are the domestic bonds "well secured" and the 96-million Sir,—In your issue of August 13, in the correspondence columns, there is published a letter, under the heading "Chinese Speculation in Railways," from a Mr. C. 8. Kwei, once a friend of mine, in which he takes serious exception to an article of mine on the same subject which appeared in the issue of August 11 In that article I wrote that the "inadequately secured" "Any bank. for could tell Mr. Kwei off hand. It's because the degree of foreign intervention behing the domestic bonds is adequate to inspire confidence in the Chinese investor; while the degree of intervention behind the 96- million bonds is not yet adequate to inspire confidence, Whenever it looks jas though the 96-million loan were Chinese, lacking sound investments, were buying up depreciatea Chinese railway bonds in the belief that foreign intervention was coming and that intervention would bring these Donds up to something like par and yield them a handsome profit. Like all returned students, Mr. Kwei has been severely bitten by the nationalistic bug and therefore resents such an insinuation so bitterly that what. ever he may have learned abroad tossed to the winds and: he proceeds to show, with typical Chinese reason-Jing, why such a situation as I have pictured is impossible in modern China, In his letter he brings in a lot of illustrative matter which only] helps him to get his line of argument} tangled, but which in the mind any well-informed reader would serve, as sufficient refutation of his argument without any comment from me, In view of the obvious weaknesses in Mr. Kwel's letter T debating with myself for some time as to whether T ought to reply toy it or not. "The only advantage in replying is to demonstrate to foreign readers how a very bright and highly educated Chinese, one of the best of the class upon which America and Europe relies for China's redemption and the resumption of normal international relations, thinks and reasons, Those who are not weill informed upon the subject that Mr. Kwei debates with me, would probably read the letter' superficially and believe that he had completely' worsted me, seeing nothing of the sophistry in it and therefore not realizing that they have before them a beautiful example of the tortuo nature of Chinese reasoning at its dest.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account