The Archive · 1930

INDIA'S FRONTIER

Aug. 12.

The news of further restlessness among the Afridis on the North-West Frontier of India has only an indirect bearing on the general political situation in India itself. Undoubtedly, that inflammable zone known as independent tribal territory has been affected by the specious propaganda of Congress agitators and by the traditional feeling that when there is internal. disorder in India favourable opportunity exists for indulgence in the chief pastime of any respectable frontiersman —raiding. In addition, the mental balance of the Pathans, whether in the North-West]

Provinces or in the Independent Tribal Territory, has to some extent been disturbed by the perfectly understandable growth. of the feeling that if some form of representative government be given to less virile people in the south, the Government should make some effort to recognize the democratic and vigorous qualities of a race which by long tradition has had very pronounced ideas on administration.

When that has been said, full recognition has been given to the political side of the ebullitions which have again found express sion in the advance of a somewhat ragged lashkar to witl uncomfortably close distance of Peshawar. There can be no doubt of the ability of the military forces on the frontier to deal with this lashkar, A glance. at the ordinary official reference book will show that the weight of the Army in India is concentrated north of the Sutlej.

Peshawar itself is the headquarters of the Northern Com-wand and also of a first-class district stretching from the Indus to the tract of Chitral in the shadow of the Pamirs. Anxiety must always be created when any part of the frontier is aflame, Fortunately, in these days of aerial reconnaissance and mobile mechanized troops, the chances of nipping in the bud a local tribal outbreak and thus preventing it from developing into a general rising are far greater than they wer rty years ago, when frontier shows" were the feature soldier's life in the North.

The frontier problem of India is unparalleled in any country in the world. It has, consequently, a very important place in the consideration of the main question of India's constitutional position. In brief, the problem may be stated thu: Pamirs to the Arabian Sea lies a strip of rugged, inhospitable country, inhabited by virile peoples for whom through the centuries the struggle against the niggardly forces of nature for a precarious and pastoral existence is eked out by raiding and inter-tribal looting. Although the various clans are ied by a common strain of Pathan blood, they are intensely individualistic, yot democratic, and, above all, cling to the primitive virtues. In that area, manhood is denied to anyone until he has "shot his man and begot his man." No amount of appeal to the soothing of Geneva would be modify those views, famous and misused quotation and never the twain shall meet' was born in the atmosphere of the frontier, and it really summed up frontier philosophy if the ending which is so often overlooked "But there is neither East ror West, Border, nor Breed, nor Birth, When two strong men stand face to face though they come from the ends of the earth!"

'This frontier tract, which lies between India and the plains of Central Asia, was for centuries the doorway' by which the invader poured down on the plains of the Punjab, and beyond. Not many miles out of Delhi, is the little village of Panipat. Three times in the history of India was the fate of India decided there in a pitched battle, and on each occasion the invader won, Since the British came to India that doorway has been shut up, and the India south of the Sutlej-has perhaps forgotten the spectras which once lurked behind that door, The independent tribal territory consists of that area in the frontier tract which lies between the Durand-Line, or the. actual political boundary between India and Afghanistan, and the confines of the Administered Districts, where the Government of India's writ runs through the normal operation of, the law. In the past there hav@)) been two schools of thought directing the policy for keeping the frontier intact. One school, called the "forward" school, advocated advance to the Durand Line along its whole length, and the conversion of whole of the territory thus absorbed into properly administered districts. The other school, called the "close border" school, maintained that the tribal territory should be lett to its own—_ diversions and that egression should be prevented by suitable punitive expeditions when occasion rose, In Baluchistan, Sandeman and Bruce carried' the "forward" policy into effect, with every success. Baluchistan, under Chief Commissioner, is as well ordered as any province in India, but between Baluchistan north ward to the Pamirs, there is narrow belt of territory to which, until 1921, the "close border"! system was roughly applied.

In 1921 the trouble between the two schools of thought was settled by Lord Rawlinson in the evolution of a compromise policy called the "half-forward" policy, which while admitting the ideal perfection of the "forward" plan, and also its prohibitive cost, provided for the peaceful penetration of the—tribal territory by means of the construction of roads and their policing by local labour, This plan was applied to what was at that time the most turbulent part of the frontier, Waziristan, and it has been' remarkably, successful. The Afridis have been spared this corrective of road-making, and although recent rents have evoked some natural, reactions in Waziristan, it is 12 the Afridi territory—the rugged Tirah—where the main trouble has. persis The problem ig to bring the Afridis to preciation of the futility of thet challenge with sufficient rapidity to prevent'restiveness finding pression further south. It should be remembered that in this unadministered tribal belt, from the east of Baluchistan to the Pamirs, there are, roughly, 500,000 fighting men, 120,000 of whom are armed with modern rifles. Any operations in that belt must have the peril which attendant on the lighting of match in a petrol store, Thank, however, to the good relations which have existed between the soldiers, the political officer. and the tribesmen, this severe test has been triumphantly with stood during the last two years—for the turmoil in Afghanistan over the insurrection again King Amanullah, the subsequent reign of Pacha-i-Saqao and the assumption of power by King; Nadir Shah was accompanied by" complete peace in British independent tribal territory. Ty those who know the frontier, this constituted an eloquent tribute to the work of the wardens of the marches. 'The present outbreak among the Afridis, cone tresting as it does with the com. parative rest in Waziristan, wilt probably raise the question whether the—"half-forward' policy should not be applied 'TTirah. The Afridis have been the spoilt children of the Frontier. There is no reagan for permitting them an indulgence which they have shown themselves quite incapable of appredating. Their—_ present. troubles will be duly adjusted in spite of the preoccupations of the Government of India elsewhere. If, as a result of this latest out break, roads are constructed ints) the heart of Tirah, good wilt come out of evil, both for the Afridis and for the sorely trict peaceful inhabitants of the Frontier Province,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account