Judgment in a Tangled Lawsuit Between Chinese Vendors, and Mr. C, P. Rakusen Judgment was given in HM. [Supreme 'Court on Monday ofter-incon, by his Honour Ji Sir Skinner Turner, in the case in which a group' of Chinese sued C.-P. Rakusen for $2,900, the agreed purchase price of optician's business in Nanking Toad. Defendant, who paid $5 alleged to be bargain money, deposited $1,000 in court, "and claimed various sums paid by. himself but for which he held plaintiffs were liable, and the principal one of these—amounting to 40 per cent. of the contract price—was allowed by his Lordship. Judgment was given for plaintiffs for $1,180, with costs.
Mr. Tycho Wing appeared for plainiiffa, and Mr, R. F.C, Mas. ter for defendants.
His Lordship said:—The plaintiffs swe here for damages for breach of contract dated February 10, 19%, in which the defendant with one R. A, Thompson agreed to buy'a business at that time running in the Nanking Rond for sum of $2,300. The defendant, while admitting the contract, effect, that the plaintiff fulfilled their part of the contract: he socks to sot off certain sums as against the pur-elise money and he brings " sium of money into Court with a denial of liability.
The plaintiffs owned this optic.
business and shortly before China New Year, 1923, wanted to dispose of it for cash. Having already been into business relations with Thompson, they are brought into connexion the defendant Rakusen' who was: pos seestd of capital:.ond was also Interested the optical business, negotiation the terms 0 purchase were agreed and were signed on. February 10, 1923, on 'a document prepared by the defendant and seen by the plaint-agent, one Tsar, for the first time on hat occasion. On Feb: ruary 11 (Sunday) the defendant' entered into possession and an wen tory was taken: he haw remained in possession ever since. He has only paid $5 (as we now know) on account of the pur chase money: and it was not! until he filed an amended defence on November 1, in thd action which had boon begun May, that he suggested liability at all in the matter by bringing: money into Court.
Tits 'TROVULE IN THK GASH, The real trouble in this case is primarily due to the fact that no provision was made in the con-react for payment, with the result that the defendant has refused to part with his money. until the plaintiffs fulfil all their covenants and the plaintiffs refuse to do anything until they get. their money. It is to say the least of it an unfortunate dispute. It is also due to the fact that the transfer of the, ex: isting lease of the premises which had some 2 months to ran was never made by the plaintiffs nor was it offered till March 13, when the defendant had made his own arrangements for a new Tease. Not that the defendant has suffer-much harm here: for he was able to obtain a fresh lease on the same terms from the landlord for the unexpired term on March 15. Certainly from. that date on: wards, the defendant had the business, the goods, ete., on the premixes and" a lease for' the agreed time; the only matters left over then' were (1) a question as to water, (2) a question as advertisements, and (3) a ques: tion as to alleged missing goods, Yet the defendant paid nothing more and has aot up to date CONTEMPTUOUS BAROAIN MONEY, Now as to the date of payment, it is true there is no express term to when this should be. But it seems to me that clause 6 shows at all events the latest date when payment should have Boon made: 60. days after occupation, The only right the defendant had to detain purchases money was given him. by that. clause: and that was only to be for an agreed. sum, I think the contract meant to provide for bargain money' signature (I cannot believe that the letter of February 15, refer: red to bargain money for no: thing), for part payment on got: ting occupation and for payment of the balance 60 days after that, ie., under the circumstances. aa they were by April 12. None' of this has been ¥: ied out, for the $5 is really almost con" temptuous as "bargain money," though T must tidd it to be such. Now the defendants were nob bound to furnish a standings: but they were bound to insert advertisement relating to their own Tinbility on such outstandings, and this they did not do: they say, as they had no, money available as no payment had boon made on account: at all events the defendant did. it, ax he has sworn, at a cost of Ma, Now the defendant seeks to sot off three items against the purchase price, and T think he is clearly entitled toa deduction for the advertivoments. As for the value of goods taken away, Tam not sadiafioat atour thin rib all: the defendant, made, hig inventory and took possession of the promises and is practically charg-Ing the' plaintiffs or one of them. with breaking in and taking away certain goods. "This. some to be based upon some statement made by Tsar and an offer of come to terms on it; but it is clear that he was anxious to gob payment and was ready to make some conesésions, No deduction can be made for this.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.