The Archive · 1920

No Testimony in Support

Plaintiffs' counsel state in their brief that "Dr. Ransom told Dr. Martin that ho accepted, on behalf of the firm, all of the terms and conditions in his addi-tonal letter of February 1."?

But, we do not find any testimony to just that effect. Only one of the plaintiffs was present when the letters were exchanged. He tes-tities that he said "this. letter (Ex. B) seems to confirm my letter (Ex. A) to you"; that defendant replied "practically it does"; and that plaintiff said: "Very well, then, we will accept the terms of this letter and consider the agreement closed." In other words, according to plaintiff's version, he accepted defendant's counter proposal on condition that it confirmed the original proposal which, as we have seen, it did not; and the same plaintiff later states that understood the counter proposal to confine defendant's portion of the fees to "new patients" which were really not mentioned therein. Clearly, then, plaintiff's mind had not met defendant's as regards the counter proposal and

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account