Dee. 8.
THERE has been, we understand, a great deal of adverse comment in local shipping circles regarding the commission which has just been appointed by the Hongkong Government to inquire] into the recent piracy of the China Navigation Co.'s str, Sunning, the story of which has already been told in these columns at length. The terms of reference under which the commission is to work are (a) to inquire how it was possible for the pirates to get on board with! arms in their possession; (b) to inquire how it was possible for pirates to seize the ship; (c) to consider the efficiency of the anti-piracy fittings ete.; and (a) to consider the supply of armed guards, the number to be carried, and their administration, The Commission appointed consists, of the Hon, EH, R. Halifax, (Chairman), the Hon. E, D. C. Wolfe, Lieut.-Commander G. F. Hole, Rk. N., Commander Miles, R. N., W. G. Goggin, Esa. and Captain A. J, Holland, The objections to the Commission, we are given to believe, are not at all to do with the terms of reference, which ave recognized as both logical and reasonable, but to the membership of the Commission and to the fact that its sittings and deliberations are to be conducted in comerd; and looking at the matter from an entirely open viewpoint, it would seem that the objections are by)
means unjustified.
Let us take the membership the Commission first, The Chairman is a highly-placed Government official; Mr. E. D. C. Wolfe, as Commissioner of Police at} Hongkong, is similarly placed; and Lieut-Commander G. F.
Hole, the Harbour-master at! Hongkong, is likewise in the direct employ of the Government. Commander Miles is an experienced naval officer; Mr. Goggin ig engaged in commerce and may! be said to have no practical knowledge of the running of a ship at sea; and Captain A, Holland, the only Mercantile! Marine officer appointed, while an officer of wide experience, has no knowledge of China Coast conditions, That the above gentlemen, one and all, will be imbued with the purest motives when the Commission sits there can be no doubt; but surely it was more than impolitic to appoint on a Commission, one of the chief duties of which will be to sift the. efficacy of the Hongkong Government's _anti-piracy regulations, three highly placed servants of the Govern. men! itself, two of whom,—the Commissioner of Police and the Harbour-master—are _direetly concerned. in the operation of those regulations! Of the abililifax, the Chairman, there can be no doubt, but again, surely, in an important inquiry such as this, where the whole anti-piracy, [system is tobe put on trial and the conduct of the officers and crew of: the ship thoroughly, sifted, one of the Colony's judges would have made a more ideal head of the Commission than ithe Secretary for Chinese Affairs. Commander Miles may be said represent naval interests and his appointment is a wise one; and no objection can be taken to /Mr. Goggin as representing commercial interests which are affected so much by the piracy, The real ground for} is the omission of any representative of the class which invariably has to bear the brunt of any piracy the officers of the ship, and in the fact that the general public, which also is not wholly] unconcerned with the piracy' question, is completely ignored. Surely the officers of China Coast, ships had the prior right of all representation in a matter which so vitally affects their welfare and their profession; and the uncomplaining public, which has suffered for so long lat the hands of the gentlemen of Bias Bay, might also have been considered, out of courtesy if nothing else.
But what appears to be cai ing the strongest comment is that the Commission is to sit in private. Why this should be so, only the Hongkong Government appears to know, and the suggestion which has come from' Hongkong that the real reason. is to prevent valuable informa~ n from reaching the pirates is unworthy of serious consideration. On principle if nothing else, there is every objection to an inquiry of this kind, affecting the travelling public to a great extent, and dealing with the conduct of the master and officers of the ship and of the Indian guards, being held behind closed: doors. The public pays for piracies and for piracy-prevention, and as officers and other members of the crew of the Sunning jove entitled to have their con-duet accorded the fullest pub-city, so also is the public entitled to know all details of the inquiry excepting, perhaps, a few matters concerning the defence of ships which only those] immediately concerned ought to know about. Secret inquiries in a matter like this are opposed to every tenet of British justice, and it is strongly to be hoped that before the Commission factually sits the double decision will have been taken of throwing, the whole inquiry open to the public and the press, and of admitting to membership at least! tone member of that branch of. the Mercantile Marine which worthily upholds the best tradi tions of the profession—th: China Coast ship's officer.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.