The Archive · 1926

IN BANKRUPTCY

U. S. Court's Ruling on Claim for Consideration as Preferred Creditor Last Friday in the United States Court for China Judge Milton 'D. Purdy delivered his decision in case of Reids Limited, Me. bankruptey, which case' has been pending before the Court since 1923." Messrs. Davies & Bryan appeared for the trustee, Mr. W. Van Buskirk, and Messrs, Chalaire Franklin for C, Lai Ting, woo was petitioning for restitution of certain property alleged to be a [part of the bankrupt estate, In his judgment, his Honour said, matter comes before me for review upon a certificate by the referee as to the legality of the referee's order of October 4, 1926, overruling a motion to strike, The ruling of the referee complained of arose in the following manner, Petition for Restitution of Property "In May, 1923, C, Lai Hing filed petition for restitution of certain Property alleged to be a part of the bankrupt estate. After a hearing on the petition, the referee in May, 1924, filed a decision adjudge ing that the trustee of the bankrupt estate pay to Hing Hk. $20,000 and declaring that Hing's claim should take preference over the claims of the general creditors after the costs Jof the administration of the estate had been paid. On June 1926, before the estate had been closed, the trustee filed with the referee a motion to reconsider the previous allowance of the claim of! Hing, whereupon Hing, by his attorney, promptly moved to strike the application of the trustee for} Jsuch reconsideration. "After hearing upon the motion, the referee filed an order in which he found that the motion was net well taken, and overruled it. C, Lai Hing filed an exception to the order of the referee and a petition for a review by the Judge of the referee's order on the ground that it was and is contrary to law, "It is the contention of counsel for the claimant, C, Lai Hing, that ithe referee is' without power to reconsider a claim which had been previously allowed by the referee, On the other hand, it is contended by the trustee that claims which huve been allowed may be reconsidered for cause. In his motion for reconsideration of the claim, Hing alleges that it affirmatively appears from the petition—for restitution, and evidence taken thereon, that the claim of Hing was not entitled to take preferences over the claims of the general creditors; that other creditors of Reids Limited were given no notice of the petition for restitution, of of the hearing or the order of the force allowing the claim of Hing'

8 preferred claim; that no) dividend has as yet been declared in the matter; and that no claim had yet been paid and that the banicruptey estate has not yet been settled or closed up; that there is Ino other material evidence which will show that Hing is not entitled to priority of payment of his claim of the general creditors, Interpretation of Bankruptey Act "The precise question for decision whether the referee has any' authority under the Bankruptcy Act to hear and consider this motion of the trustee for a reconsideration of the claim of C. Lai Hing. Such orestion depends for its solution pon the interpretation which the Court should give to paragraph K of Sec. 57 of the Bankruptey Aet."

After quoting authorities on the subject his Honour concluded:—"Upon the record of this case as it now stands, it is my opinion that the claim of C. Lai Hing for restoration of certain moneys which he claims were held by ths bankrupt in trust prior to the institution of the Froceedings, and which claim. was allowed as a preference by the referee in his order of May, 1924, should be reconsidered by the referee. It is, therefore, ordered and adjudged, that the order of the referee of October 4, 1926, overruling the motion to strike. the trustee's application to the referee for a reconsideration of the claim of C. Lai Hing, be sustained." morning when she brought the baby'

The petition was granted,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account