The Archive · 1931

Lawyer Not Authorized

An action brought by Messrs. Atkinson & Dallas in H.M. Supreme Court before Judge King on January: 22 was dismissed and costs given against plaintiff. Counsel for defence described the failure of plaintiff's representative to produce a power of attorney as "only an example of the negligence which has characterized this ease from besinning to end."

Mr. T. K, Ting appeared for Messrs. Atkinson & Dallas, and described himself as an "attorney in fact" for the firm, and claimed that he was member of that firm's staff, Mr. K. E. Newman, for the defence, stated that he understood that Mi Ting was a member of the American law firm of Messrs, Fleming Allman, Judge King then told Mr. Ting that before he could appear he must file a Power of Attorney, according to the Orders in Council, if he were not a qualified legal practitioner of the British Court. Mr. Ting affirm ed that he had a general power of W. fattcrney, and asked leave Messrs. Atkinson & Dallas' ofice to fetch it.

Mr. Newman then told the court that if there were any adjournment must ask for costs, His client, Mrs. Brock, was being sued for arrears of rent from May to September last, inclusive, but he was in possession of receipts which showed that. everything had been paid. His client was a busy woman, While witness for defence, Mr. Lienard, was a busy man, and their time was being wasted.

After an adjournment of 15 minutes, however, Mr. Ting re-4p-peared in court and handed over to the judge a chit, dated that morning and made out during the st few minutes, purporting to authorize him to act, The judge remonstrated with Mr. Ting stating that he thought the latter had' said he held a general power of attorney, Mr. Ting remarked that he thought the chit would be sufficient for the day, the judge pointed out that Messrs. Atkinson & Pallas were a Timited' company, and that any power of attorney should bear the company's seal and signatures as prescribed.

Mr. Ting said that he had misunderstood the judge regarding the power of attorney. The judge stated "You didn't" and Mr, Newman remarked "My lord, if T may say 50, I don't believe he's got tone." Asked by the judge who had igned the chit he brought, Mr, Ting said "Probably "Mr." Saker." Judge King said "We can't go on Mr. Newman-thereupon produced five receipts for the rent for the five months as claimed by Mr. Ting, and asked the judge to dismiss the case, with costs against plaintiffs, stating that he could not understand a responsible firm allowing an irresponsible person to use a court Tike this, Judge King then explained jearefully to. Mr. Ting that plaintiff were a very old frm, and twere duly registered in Hongkong. They must give their Power of Attorney under seal: their articles of association say 20. If Mr. Ting had a general power of attorney, sealed by the company and signed bby the secretary and two directors, Ihe would find a clause authorizing him (o proceed in court in their Mr. Ting stated that he was a Chinese lawyer, was not familier with British procedure, and mast ask to withdraw his representations land ask Messrs. Atkinson & Dallas to allow a British lawyer to take his place, Tadge King refused this, saying "Here are five receipts. I cannot allow you to appear, nor can [allow Jan adjournment. I said that yea [were to produce your general power attorney, and you haven't got it, only a. chit signed after you left court. Have you a Power of Mr. Ting answered "Yes" and [ssid that he must go back to his office again to get it. He once more asked to withdraw the case jand allow.a British lawyer cary on, as he did not understand the rales, but was told by the Judge that be was making no discriminations, only following the rules of the court, Mr. Newman' remarked that 'Mr. Ting must understand' powers of attorney, and that the Chinese courts were far more strict than the British courts. He could not appear in any eases in the Chinese courts except under Concluding by stating that Mr. Ting's actions were only an example of the negligence which had characterized the ease from beginning to end, and had given him a defence, Mr. Newman asked that the action be dismissed and costs given against plaintiff, Judge King granted this,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account