The Archive · 1931

Motor Exchange Sued In HM, Supreme Court on January 26 before Judge

King, Lieut-Comdr, Thomas Henry Taber, of the U.S. Navy, represented on Power of Attorney by It. W. B, Onley, of the U.S. Marine Corps, claimed against the Cathay Motor Exchange (and Mr.

H. Spencer, its manager) for 400 said to be due in respect egod that the Exchange had agreed to buy It. Commander Taber's car prior to his departure Hfor the United States Inst October fand had given It. Onley a cheque for the amount claimed which was dishonoured on November 7. The defence was that It. Commander Taber or his representative, It. JOnley, had agreed not to press for payment of the purchase price unfit judgment obtained in the Special District Court had been satisfied.

Mr. M. B, Brown represented It. Commander' Taber; Mr. Spencer appeared in person.

Judgment was given for the Jamount claimed, with costs.

It. Onley, giving evidence, that It. Commander Taber ud authorized him to collect the sum launed, After repeated efforts to obtain satisfaction from the Exchange and/or the return of the car Thad been given a cheque, which Twas subsequently dishonoured, amined by Mr. Spencer, denied that he had ever agreed to await satisfac tion. of @ District Court, judgment for Tis, 1,000 which had been given in favour of the Exchange, On either December 80 or 31 he had Jocen a Mr. Dodd, representing the Exchange, ud had then agreed to wait for thrap or four days for a Final settlement, This. agreement foe had cancelled on January 2 when Ihe discovered that It, Comniander Taber's car was being "ran about" by "the Exchange despite their {failure to pay for it. He had, he said, seen it parked in' Avene Mr. R. J. Dodd, who described lnimselt as Secretary and Treasurer lof the Exchange and an American citizen, said that he had seen It. [Onley on December 81, when it was mutually agreed that, subject to the [guarantee of a Chinese lawyer who was concerned with the" District (Court judgment, no further st would be taken to enture payment the amount claimed. He had fuct, however, arranged that gua ntee, contenting himself with ing It. Onley the name and address the Chinese lawyer.

After a lengthy statement from Mz. Spencer, which Mr. Brown leharacterized' as "irrelevant nonsense," judgment was given as stated, his Lordship adding that whereas it appeared to be part of Mr. Spencer's ease, and that of the Exchange, which he represented, that It. 'Onley, on behalf of It. Commander Taber, had made promises which he had not' Kept it should be remembered by him that fin law there was 0 consideration for a promise. The facts we plain: The Exchange still had 1 fear, they had not paid for it, and they had made no. tangible effort to pay for it. He was quite satisfied that Ar. Spencer was the responsible party since according to. his Jown statements the Exchange wax private company with Britich (Gtr. Spencer), American, and. Chinese partners, any one of whom leould'be sued for its liabilities the court which had proper jurisdiction,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account