Nov. 28.
Two items of news published this week cannot be allowed to pass without comment. The "North-China Daily Mail" has announced the discovery of the dead bodies of sixty-three coolies Un two railway trucks near' Tientsin, and an appalling story is related in that connexion.
The coolies, victims of the press gang, were herded into these trucks along with a number of mules, and the doors secured to prevent their escape. The trucks then appear to have been forgotten, and the men and animals, unable to get out, suffered the tortures of death by starvation. Not a solitary man survived to tell the story. fu the first place we need not be surprised in the least on account of the fact that these two trucks were overlooked, for even under the most favourable conditions war is invariably waged in the midst of confusion, and it is the general who can, out of what is really' chaos, place a well ordered army) on the battlefield, who goes down to history as the successful_ leader. In justice to the staffs of the Chinese armies which fought in the north, it has to be pointed out that the mislaying of a couple of trucks is the sort of thing that would occur in connexion with any] force, and it is worth mentioning that at the start of the Great}
War the German General Staff is alleged to have completely forgotten the existence of a whole division. The case was mentioned in the memoirs of German officer, and doubtless it could be. capped by ° equally amazing episodes from other an The fact, however is that the division did not starve to death.
While, therefore, in one respect we have simply seen a common. incident of warfare, the consequences reveal a hideous crime. In the first place it was not a national war which was} being waged: there was _no enemy against whom China had to arm. The latter case alone could justify the conscription of these unhappy creatures. They: were, however, conscripted, and until they could be brought to] the war zone were held prisoners. Here is where either the callousness or the.criminal carelessness of those in command must be denounced in the strongest terms. To save the necessity of mounting a guard over these trucks, the men in charge merely tied the doors with wire, making it impossible for them to be opened from the} inside, and so. the. tragedy. was enacted. All that was demanded fromthe military point of view] was:':-corporal's guard whose presence in the first place would have been sufficient to prevent the escape of the men and in the second would have prevented the tragedy either by releasing the prisoners or reporting the matter to the nearest authority—even in the Chinese army a transport offer could not be far distant. Nothing' of' the kind, however, took place, and. to-day an appalling crime must be laid at the. door of China's soldiers, not the rank arid file but those holding commissions. In answer to our condemnation we shall probably be told that in all other wars there have been' instances of cruelty—brutal treatment of prisoners, inadequate arrangements for the care of the wounded, futile _commigsariat arrangements leading to the troops being half starved. and so forth. All perfectly true, and these are the things which rob war of whatever glory it has been supposed to possess, but the nations boasting the highest civilization have always striven, though frequently not success: fully, to remedy them. The pos tion is, however, that they have reached a stage where even in the midst of war such gross negligence as was displayed at Tientsin could not happen. What we have just seen is a serious blow to the much vaunted efficiency of China's armies, a tradition to which the recent fighting has given rise, and it has to be remembered.
The second item of news to which attention should specially be called is with reference to the capture of Mr. Anda of the Norwegian Lutheran Mission in Honan. His captors have offered to exchange him for a mission-school girl, and such a proposal, redolent to us of the dark demands as much public the' preceding episode which we have mentioned. We are actually modern China back to the point where woman is considered a chattel, something for bargaining with. We may assume that a particular girl is wanted in this case, and the possible reasons for the bandit chief's demand are many. Foreign residents of many years' stand-and intimately acquainted with the interior of China state that at times a Chinese girl will enter a mission school or convent primarily for the reason that she wishes to avoid a disagreeable marriage, and if this should be the case we can perhaps see here a proposal to kidnap an unwilling bride for a desirous husband. It might also be that she is the daughter of a wealthy man and that. it would be more profitable to hold her than a missionary to ransom. These are two possibilities arising out of an episode which is said to be practically unparalleled in China, and they give a striking idea of the state of the country. Let them be borne in mind, especially when next the glib politicians who represent China at foreign conferences start to talk about extraterritoriality.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.